Thoughts after finishing the game
Well, for starters, what a trip, completely worth the money, even if it's only year one.
Now, with that said, I think I had the completely opposite experience to some of the people in this sub. The game is not easy, yes, but i think that it was quite manageable, specially for someone that went mostly blind (I did play the demo, and my savefile didn't transfer, so I kinda got to play the first week and have a go at it again)
I played on Grim, which I understand is the intended difficulty. I didn't have any character die on me, completed all town projects with relative ease. I think the only time I was racing to meet the quota was after the ration demands where increased to 20. Herbivores are hard to supply. Besides that, I don't think I've had any problems during most of my playthrough. In fact, during Fall i got to keep 10 days of rations over the quota at least after the initial hurdle, and met the Winter quota on day 6, with a 10 days surplus by day 12.
Now, as I said before, I don't think the game is easy per se, but for someone that went in blind, used the wiki sparingly (only for the wine recipe, and where to get the last 4 fish of the collection) and made A LOT of mistakes (Upgraded tools too late, didn't buy Girtles until last days of fall, lots of rations rotted before being eaten due to poor handling on my part, the godawful layout you can see on the image, being late into sprinklers, etc) my playthrough was smooth, and I even got to have a few days where I didn't do shit, cuz everything was already taken care of and decided to just skip it/go talk to the npcs.
And I can imagine my setup was in no sense optimal, I mean, look how much space is wasted, and in retrospective I could have maybe gotten double or triple output on some stuff If I were to consider some late info. (Skins and wool have basically no use except for selling, fertilizer is basically infinite and sells for a lot in a pinch, Girtles are op, cooking is op, the lost and found box in theo's room is a source of free money, Percy's weather forecast is 100% accurate, so you should coordinate what he says with your tool upgrades.
For a new playthrough, I think I would like to see what interacting more with the townsfolk would bring. I didn't give many gifts while playing, since I never really did in Stardew Valley and other games like that. I know that they do give you gifts back, since Percy gave me peanut butter every so often, but I don't know if it's really worth the trouble. I also don't know if the romance is really implemented. Might wanna grab some piece of tail, if you know what Im saying.
But that's that.