RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/HarryPotteronHBO • … • u/LadyGramarye

They have totally cast Voldemort and it's probably a star- here's why I think so:

There's been a lot of chatter about whether the show has cast Voldemort. Maybe it's just the posts I've been seeing, but I've seen a general consensus that they likely have not, or that they may have, but that we shouldn't expect anyone particularly well-known bc of the logistics of how the industry works. Here's why I think that's wrong:

They are bothering to remake the (hopefully) entire Harry Potter series, and are branding the project as "book accurate" and "with room for the story to breathe" before all else.

The grand finale of bk 1, so to speak, is that Harry comes face-to-face, literally, with Voldemort. It's supposed to be a shock for the audience and for Harry. The face he sees is supposed to haunt him until he finally sees him emerging from the cauldron in Book 4. We are also supposed to have some jump-scares of Harry seeing Voldemort's face in his dreams, and disturbing moments when Harry hears his mother pleading with Volde, and later his father defending them, as he's experiencing the effects of the Dementors.

So how can any of this be effective, exciting, scary, showstopper moments, if the actor playing him won't be back? And why would a major, expensive HBO production use the largely-unknown actor Luke Thallon, or some other fairly-unknown actor, to portray a Big Bad that needs much more mystique, and menacing aura compared to the movies, to an international audience?

I think the answer is that they wouldn't, and they have cast someone, and probably have already recorded the actor performing Voldemort's confrontation with Harry in a studio somewhere private (or they will record it, right before the season or episode drops). I think they will use their considerable resources to move heaven and earth to turn the Volde casting into a huge draw that will suck audience members in at the end of the season and keep them coming back next year.

The people saying "no A-lister would sign on for a 10-year tv commitment" are wrong. First of all, the "TV < movies" mentality is dying if not dead, as prestige TV with massive budgets and movie-quality visuals draw enormous views and generates massive stars that go on to become major movie stars. Second, Voldemort is not a full-time cast member. He essentially has one scene in book 1, tiny cameos or total absence in 2 and 3, until book 4, when he has one (albeit long) scene. Then Book 5 picks up with a handful of short scenes, one duel scene, and a smattering of shots of Volde probably feeling certain emotions to overlay over Harry, book 6 only a few short flashback scenes, and then obviously very heavy involvement in book 7. Basically, the actor only needs to really clear his schedule for book 7, and that's it.

Personally, I think they have cast a major British actor who is probably a talented voice actor, which I think is the key to Voldemort, and who is likely tall and slender. My hope is Christian Bale (who is an incredible voice actor), or Benedict Cumberbatch, although they are very expensive. Possibly Matthew McFadyen, Bill Skarsgård, Paul Bettany. Nicholas Hoult- did HBO ever officially confirm he was Lockhart? I do think they would consider Tilda Swinton in makeup as a male Voldemort, although obviously that would be very controversial to some.

Am I right? Totally delulu? Only time will tell!

What do you guys think?

— 0