RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/HelldiversUnfiltered • … • u/TheRedHandedOne

Solution to almost every problem with the major order system

In the ttrpg pathfinder, determining success is based on a degree system rather than simply a pass/fail system, like in DnD and Helldivers 2. It’s a very good system because it also makes the storytelling more dynamic and gives GMs more to work with. That said, this latest failure kind of pissed me off, because it stems from the issue that nobody but me and the mouse in my pocket like fighting the squids right now. Sure, that’ll change in a week for a week, but having a degrees of success system would fix almost every balance problem major orders encounter.

Let’s apply this to the latest one. We need to get 90 million rare samples from two planets. Let’s break that down

Critical Success: we did it with several days to spare. Bonus medals awarded and an experimental stratagem once the samples are processed.

Success: major order completed in time. Medals awarded.

Partial Success/Failure: entire goal was not met but 2 criteria out of three were met and the failed one was failed only barely. Reduced medal reward, BUT we will be at least partially prepared for what the squids will do next

Failure: we fail. Unimpressive performance, no reward

Critical failure: lack of coordination and misuse of resources leads to the squids gaining an initial strategic advantage in their next move. In this case, this would happen if we lost the planet we were supposed to hold and got less than 50% of the needed samples, but in other cases could result in applicable logistics penalties or whatnot.

This kind of system would give JOEL a lot more to play with and would increase player investment in the story, mission, and set up opportunities to reward exceptional player base unity like what was done with the DSS on Super Earth and Cyberstan. Sure, as those events prove, the devs can already do that on a whim, but this system would provide more clear guidelines on when to do it. Plus, for drama, it could still be done whenever.

— 0