Lore of the wayward compass?
charms are created from either a dying wish, a strong emotion, formed naturally, created by a higher being, or forged by a regular bug, the wayward compass doesnt have alot of details on its lore but the fact that its bought from by iselda can limit where this charm originates from, as of this point cornifer has only visited the forgotten crossroads dirtmouth and the howling cliff so cornifer couldve only obtained it from these locations
it couldnt have been formed from cornifer or iselda, i had a theory that it was formed from the strong feelings of the marriage of cornifer and iselda or created by cornifers strong enjoyment of exploring but they wouldnt sell it so casually if it was so they must've found it somewhere, cornifer is likely selling it because he has no use for it he already marks his face on his maps ( as shown in the forgotten crossroads map before you get a quill )
the wayward compass likely originates from the wastelands cornifer and iselda traveled through as there are only two corpses that died in howling cliffs one died against mato the other died of unknown causes fleeing from the pale king so we cant link it to either of these two ( theres also the grimm troupe and joni's corpses but i dont think they count as i dont a fucking compass was gifted by the nightmare heart or lifeblood god ) cornifer left his hometown early so he couldnt have been gifted it by a parental figure he must have found it along the way to hallownest
hallownest was a common place for pilgrims to visit i believe maybe perchance the wayward compass came from dying corpse of an explorer whos final goal was to visit hallownest but perished before they could reach it and so their final wish was that whoever finds his corpse may make it to hallownest being cornifer and iselda
conclusion : the wayward compass was owned by a mysterious explorer who wanted to visit hallownest but died before they could reach it their final wish became the wayward compass which was found by cornifer and sold by iselda as some random junk they found
this is heavy speculation and if anyone has an rebuttals of this theory please tell me them i really wish we had more lore about lesser lore heavy charms like these i might do more charm lore posts like this for less lore heavy charms but only if people like it