How do you think the Brosnan and Craig's Bonds would have worked with Bernard Lee/Robert Brown’s M, and how would Judi Dench’s M have worked with Connery, Lazenby, Moore and Dalton's Bonds?
I’ve been thinking about how much the personality of M changes the dynamic with Bond, and I’m curious what everyone here thinks about some hypothetical pairings we never got to see.
Personally, I think Brosnan would have fit extremely naturally with either Bernard Lee or Robert Brown. His Bond is probably the closest of the later Bonds to the traditional idea of the polished, professional Secret Service officer who respects the hierarchy even when he bends the rules. I could easily imagine Lee’s M having a relationship with Brosnan similar to the one he had with Connery, where he clearly trusts Bond as one of his best agents but is constantly exasperated by him. Brown and Brosnan would probably work really well too, maybe with a slightly more paternal dynamic.
Craig with Lee or Brown would be much more interesting. Early Craig especially would probably drive Lee absolutely insane with his insubordination, recklessness and tendency to treat orders as suggestions. I think he would have to earn Lee’s respect much more than Connery or Brosnan did. By the time you get to the more mature Bond of Skyfall, though, I think Lee would respect his loyalty enormously. Brown and Craig could potentially have an even more confrontational version of the Brown/Dalton relationship in Licence to Kill, with Bond going rogue and M constantly threatening to revoke his licence.
Going in the other direction, this is where I think it gets especially interesting. Obviously, you have to suspend some disbelief given how difficult it would have been to imagine a woman as the head of MI6 in the 1960s or 1970s, but I think Judi Dench’s M with Connery would have been fantastic.
Connery’s Bond is so confident, arrogant and accustomed to charming or intimidating his way through situations, while Dench’s M is probably the one person who would be completely immune to it. I also think she might have had to be noticeably sterner and more hard-nosed with Connery’s Bond than with some of the others, at least initially.
Given the way Connery’s Bond behaves around women and some of the very old-school attitudes he displays, I’m not sure he would immediately take a female M as seriously as he did Bernard Lee’s version, or show her quite the same instinctive deference. I could see him testing her authority, being a little too casual or patronising at first, and trying to use his usual charm to get around her.
Dench’s M would absolutely not tolerate that. If anything, I think it would force her to be even stricter, more commanding and more openly willing to put him in his place. Their early relationship could be especially combative, with Connery constantly testing boundaries and Dench immediately seeing through him and making it very clear who was in charge.
But once Connery’s Bond realised that she was every bit as formidable, intelligent and competent as any male M, I think he would come to genuinely respect her. From there, I could see the relationship developing into a lot of verbal sparring and mutual irritation, but also a considerable amount of respect and even affection underneath it.
Lazenby is also a really interesting one to imagine with Dench because his Bond is much more openly vulnerable and emotionally driven than Connery’s. He’s still cocky and rebellious, but in OHMSS you also see him become frustrated with M, seriously consider resigning, fall genuinely in love with Tracy and then suffer an enormous personal loss.
I think Dench’s M would see through him very quickly and recognise that underneath the bravado, he actually feels things very deeply. Their relationship could be quite combative at first, especially whenever Bond gets petulant or treats a mission like a personal crusade, but I could also imagine it becoming surprisingly close and almost maternal over time.
After Tracy’s death especially, I think Dench’s M would understand his grief while also being one of the few people capable of telling him that he couldn’t allow vengeance to consume him. In some ways, I think Lazenby/Dench might have ended up somewhere between Dalton/Dench and Craig/Dench.
Dench and Moore might actually be really funny together. Moore would probably respond to her criticism by becoming even more charming and flippant, while she would see straight through him. I also think she’d be frequently annoyed by his excessive skirt-chasing and tendency to get involved with seemingly every attractive woman he encounters, probably regarding it as both unprofessional and an unnecessary distraction from the job. Moore, naturally, would probably just smile and deflect whenever she called him out on it, which might irritate her even more. At the same time, I think she’d probably trust Moore’s Bond quite a lot because he’s generally emotionally controlled, highly experienced and dependable when it really matters, even when he’s bending the rules.
The pairing I’d most like to have seen, though, might be Dench and Dalton. Would it be basically similar to Craig/Dench? I always so Dalton's Bond as a prototype for Craig's Bond. Dalton’s Bond is much more emotional than he likes to admit, particularly when people he cares about are hurt, and Dench’s M is exactly the kind of character who would recognise that and challenge him over it.
I could imagine their arguments being incredibly intense, especially in something like Licence to Kill. She’d probably understand exactly why he was going after Sanchez while still telling him that it wasn’t his private war. I think she would see Dalton’s loyalty as simultaneously his greatest strength and his biggest weakness.
So how do you think these combinations would have worked? Which pairing do you think would have had the best chemistry, which one would have been the most interesting dramatically, and which Bond do you think would have clashed with a different M the most?