RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/Jewish • … • u/eyoxa

Dealing with ignorance

My ex husband is Mexican and not Jewish (as in literally lived in Mexico up until five years ago). All of his family are still in Mexico. I was born in Ukraine and have lived in the U.S. since childhood. I am Jewish. We have a 4 year old.

His sister came to visit and I included her in some of the things I was doing with my daughter while he was working. One of these things was a Rosh Hashanah celebration at the synagogue that involved a communal dinner. Before going I had asked her if she wanted to attend, and she said yes. I was worried that she might have ignorant anti-Jewish or anti-Israel sentiments and I didn’t want to feel embarrassed by her bringing these up in that space.

From the start the evening with her fell off. First, she seemed surprised that I am Jewish and asked what I believe. I explained that I am an atheist and do not believe in anything. With a role of her eyes, she then questioned why I was here then. It is cultural for me I explained. Then I followed up with how Jews in Ukraine and Eastern Europe faced discrimination and suffering throughout the centuries, and how important it is for me to maintain that connection to my heritage. That it is also why I gave my daughter a distinctly Jewish name.

Then she asked me if I believed in Jesus Christ and who he was for the Jews. I said I do not and that he is nobody for the Jews. She seemed shocked, and I was surprised at her level of ignorance as she’s a fairly educated person and well read, I’d thought.

She questioned me more in the same way, and I told her more about the suffering of Jews over the past century and beyond although it did not feel like a topic I wanted to engage in the space we were in. Then she interrupted me and said that this was not what she’d read in a book and that Palestine…

I stopped her right there. Said this had nothing to do with Palestine. That I was talking about Eastern Europe and my family.

That was the end of the Palestinian thread of the conversation, but it was kind of what I was fearing and anticipating at the same time. And yet 24 hours later, I find myself feeling kind of annoyed that this person, ignorant of my history felt like she had a right to make claims about it because she’d read a few chapters in a book.

I am raising a Jewish daughter. And if anyone ever holds a gun to my head to ask, I will say “I am Jewish, just like my mother, and her mother, and the many mothers before her.”

— 0