DNA evidence in the Ramsey case: FAQs and common misconceptions
#Frequently Asked Questions
_________________________
###What are the main pieces of DNA evidence in the Ramsey case?
[from /u/Heatherk79]:
Discussion of the DNA evidence in the Ramsey case is typically related to one of the following pieces of evidence: underwear, fingernails, long johns, nightgown or ligatures. More information can be found [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/JonBenetRamsey/comments/opbgg4/major_rounds_of_dna_testing_in_the_jonbenet/).
###Is DNA ever possibly going to solve the JonBenet case?
[from [Mitch Morrissey](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitchell_R._Morrissey#Use_of_DNA_evidence_in_prosecution), former Ramsey grand jury special deputy prosecutor -- [source](https://thecraigsilvermanshow.podbean.com/e/episode-8-morning-light/) (3:21:05)]:
>It could. ... The problem with using genetic genealogy on that [sample] is it's a mixture, so when you go to sequence it, you're gonna get both persons' types in the sequence. And it's a very, very small amount of DNA. And for genetic genealogy, to do sequencing, you need a lot more DNA than what you're used to in the criminal system. So where you could test maybe eight skin cells and get a profile and, you know, solve your murder or exonerate an innocent person, you can't do that with sequencing. You've got to have a pretty good amount of DNA.
###Is it true that we can use the same technology in the Ramsey case as was used in the Golden State Killer Case?
[from /u/straydog77 -- [source](https://www.reddit.com/r/JonBenetRamsey/comments/ebhua8/tabloid_scumbag_dylan_howard_and_his_team_neglect/)]:
>The Golden State Killer case used SNP profiles derived from the suspect's semen, which was found at the scene.
>In the Ramsey case, we have a 10-marker STR profile deduced from ... a DNA mixture, which barely meets the minimum requirements for CODIS. You cannot do a familial search like in the Golden State case using an STR profile. You need SNP data.
>To extract an SNP profile, we would need a lot more DNA from "unidentified male 1". If we can somehow find that, we can do a familial DNA search like they did in Golden State. But considering "unidentified male 1" had to be enhanced from 0.5 nanograms of DNA in the first place, and analysts have literally been scraping up picograms of Touch DNA to substantiate UM1's existence, the chance of stumbling upon another significant deposit of his DNA on any case evidence is practically zero.
#Common Misconceptions
______________ ###Foreign DNA matched between the underwear and her fingernails.
[from /u/heatherk79 -- [source](https://www.reddit.com/r/JonBenetRamsey/comments/in2cuz/2001_nbc_dateline_explores_lou_smits_intruder/g46tvkk/)]:
>There wasn't enough of a profile recovered from either the panties or the fingernails in 1997 to say the samples matched.
>You can see the 1997 DNA report which includes the original testing of the underwear and fingernails here:
>* [Page 1](https://imgur.com/3eLckvJ)
>* [Page 2](https://imgur.com/zsTd3No)
>Page 2 shows the results of the panties (exhibit #7), the right-hand fingernails (exhibit 14L) and left-hand fingernails (exhibit 14M.) All three samples revealed a mixture of which JBR was the major contributor.
>For each of those three exhibits, you will see a line which reads: (1.1, 2), (BB), (AB), (BB), (AA), (AC), (24,26). That line shows JBR's profile. Under JBR's profile, for each of the three exhibits, you will see additional letters/numbers. Those are the foreign alleles found in each sample. The “W” listed next to each foreign allele indicates that the allele was weak.
>The (WB) listed under the panties, shows that a foreign B allele was identified at the GC locus.
>The (WB), (WB) listed under the right-hand fingernails shows that a B allele was identified at the D7S8 locus and a B allele was identified at the GC locus.
>The (WA), (WB), (WB), (W18) listed under the left-hand fingernails show that an A allele was identified at the HBGG locus, a B allele was identified at the D7S8 locus, a B allele was identified at the GC locus and an 18 allele was identified at the D1S80 locus.
>A full profile would contain 14 alleles (two at each locus). However, as you can see, only one foreign allele was identified in the panties sample, only two foreign alleles were identified in the right-hand fingernails sample and only four foreign alleles were identified in the left-hand fingernails sample.
>None of the samples revealed anything close to a full profile (aside from JBR's profile.) It's absurd for anyone to claim that the panties DNA matched the fingernail DNA based on one single matching B allele.
>It's also important to note that the type of testing used on these samples was far less discriminatory than the type of testing used today.
[from /u/straydog77 -- [source](https://www.reddit.com/r/JonBenetRamsey/comments/ea5x0k/why_do_so_many_people_want_jonbenets_death_to_be/fapnjdn/)]:
>You're referring to a DNA test from 1997 which showed literally **one allele** for the panties. If we are looking at things on the basis of **one allele**, then we could say Patsy Ramsey matched the DNA found on the panties. So did John's brother Jeff Ramsey. So did much of the US population.
###The same unknown male DNA profile was found in 3 separate places (underwear, long johns, beneath fingernails).
[from /u/heatherk79 -- [source](https://www.reddit.com/r/JonBenetRamsey/comments/ix49ji/do_three_dna_samples_all_match/g698ewp/)]:
>Not exactly.
>There wasn't enough genetic material recovered (in 1997) from either the underwear or the fingernails to say the samples matched. [Here](https://www.reddit.com/r/JonBenetRamsey/comments/in2cuz/2001_nbc_dateline_explores_lou_smits_intruder/g46tvkk/) is a more detailed explanation regarding the underwear and fingernail DNA samples.
>The fingernail samples were tested in 1997 by the CBI. Older types of DNA testing (DQA1 + Polymarker and D1S80) were used at that time. The profiles that the CBI obtained from the fingernails in 1997 could not be compared to the profiles that Bode obtained from the long johns in 2008. The testing that was done in 1997 targeted different markers than the testing that was done in 2008.
>The underwear were retested in 2003 using STR analysis (a different type of testing than that used in 1997.) After some work, Greg LaBerge of the Denver Crime Lab, was able to recover a profile which was later submitted to CODIS. This profile is usually referred to as "Unknown Male 1."
>After learning about "touch" DNA, Mary Lacy (former Boulder D.A.) sent the underwear and the long johns to Bode Technology for more testing in 2008. You can find the reports [here](https://ramseyroom.files.wordpress.com/2024/03/20080324-bodelabreport.pdf) and [here](https://ramseyroom.files.wordpress.com/2024/03/20080620-bodereport.pdf).
>Three small areas were cut from the crotch of the underwear and tested. Analysts, however, were unable to replicate the Unknown Male 1 profile.
>Four areas of the long johns were also sampled and tested; the exterior top right half, exterior top left half, interior top right half and interior top left half. The exterior top right half revealed a mixture of at least two individuals including JBR. The Unknown Male 1 profile couldn't be excluded as a contributor to this mixture. The partial profile obtained from the exterior top left half also revealed a mixture of at least two individuals including JBR. The Unknown Male 1 profile couldn't be included or excluded as a contributor to this mixture. The remaining two samples from the long johns also revealed mixtures, but the samples weren't suitable for comparison.
>Lab analysts made a note on the first report stating that it was likely that more than two individuals contributed to each of the exterior long john mixtures, and therefore, the remaining DNA contribution to each mixture (not counting JBR's) should not be considered a single source profile. [Here's](https://archive.ph/hvUGr) a news article/video explaining the caveat noted in the report.
>**TLDR;** There wasn't enough DNA recovered from the fingernails or the underwear in 1997 to say the samples matched. In 2003, an STR profile, referred to as Unknown Male 1, was developed from the underwear. In 2008, the long johns were tested. The Unknown Male 1 profile couldn't be excluded from one side of the long johns, and couldn't be included or excluded from the other side of the long johns. Analysts, however, noted that neither long johns profile should be considered a single source profile.
###The source of the unknown male DNA in JonBenet's underwear was saliva.
[from /u/heatherk79 -- [source](https://www.reddit.com/r/JonBenetRamsey/comments/kym1rv/2020_special_and_dna/gjj4uog/)]:
>The [results](https://ramseyroom.files.wordpress.com/2024/03/19980901-cbirpt.pdf) of the serological testing done on the panties for amylase (an enzyme found in saliva) were inconclusive.
[from u/straydog77 -- [source](https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueCrimeDiscussion/comments/fhfjq0/jonbenet_ramsey_forensic_scientist_thinks/fkbc2mc/)]:
>As for the idea that the "unidentified male 1" DNA comes from saliva, it seems this was based on a presumptive amylase test which was done on the sample. Amylase can indicate the presence of saliva or sweat. Then again, those underwear were soaked with JBR's urine, and it's possible that amylase could have something to do with that.
###The unknown male DNA from the underwear was "co-mingled" with JonBenet's blood.
[from /u/straydog77 -- [source](https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueCrimeDiscussion/comments/fhfjq0/jonbenet_ramsey_forensic_scientist_thinks/fkbc2mc/)]:
>[T]his word "commingled" comes from the Ramseys' lawyer, Lin Wood. "Commingled" doesn't appear in any of the DNA reports. In fact, the word "commingled" doesn't even have any specific meaning in forensic DNA analysis. It's just a fancy word the Ramsey defenders use to make the DNA evidence seem more "incriminating", I guess.
>The phrase used by DNA analysts is "mixed DNA sample" or "DNA mixture". It simply refers to when you take a swab or scraping from a piece of evidence and it is revealed to contain DNA from more than one person. It means there is DNA from more than one person in the sample. It doesn't tell you anything about *how* or *when* any of the different people's DNA got there. So if I bleed onto a cloth, and then a week later somebody else handles that cloth without gloves on, there's a good chance you could get a "mixed DNA sample" from that cloth. I suppose you could call it a "commingled DNA sample" if you wanted to be fancy about it.