Real or Not real? A guide for Enameled Cast Iron legitimacy.
This is not an exhaustive guide, and I am writing as someone who lives in the US, so it may be different where you are. Additionally, it focuses on modern pieces (post 2000), as there was not a market for fakes 25 years ago. **So if it is vintage, don't bother asking if it is fake.** It might have been misidentified, but it isn't "fake." Like maybe it is listed as Le Creuset but it is actually Descoware, etc. Basically, if the bottom is flat and fully enameled, it is probably post 2000. If it is black, ridged, has a heat ring, a diamond mark, etc. don't ask. No one cared back then.
Here are some key things to look for when you find yourself asking, "Is this modern piece legit?"
For starters, there are basically two lines of Le Creuset ECI in production, Traditional and Signature. Hallmarks of Traditional pieces vs. Signature:
* The handles of Traditional pieces are smaller (refer to photo 1) or solid (refer to photo 2). * The rings are thinner on Traditional and thicker on Signature (photo 3). * The Traditional knob will be black with a logo or stainless without a bevel (photo 4), although knobs can be switched out, so that's not super-useful. * The information inside the lid will be indented on Traditional and raised on Signature (photo 5).
Facts to know:
* There are Outlet-specific colors, such as vapeur, bamboo, provence, cobalt, turquoise (though recently discontinued), etc. However, there are Signature and Traditional pieces in many colors. Finding a Traditional piece in a Signature color does not mean it is fake, and vice versa. * There are TJX specific colors, as well: sky blue, chili, and onyx. Marshalls, Home Goods, and TJMaxx all sell these pieces occasionally. Often they are second choix (seconds), but not always. Typically they are traditional. They often get a few random other things, as well. You can frequently find some stoneware hiding in a TJX store. **So, yes, if you got it from a TJX store, it is real; don't bother asking.**
Let's start with "for the most part" truths. *For the most part:*
* Traditional pieces are sold at the Outlets and Signature pieces are sold at authorized retailers (Crate & barrel, Williams-Sonoma, your local kitchen store, etc.) and on the Le Creuset site. If you want to know if a store is and authorized retailer, contact [[email protected]](https://mail.google.com/mail/?view=cm&fs=1&tf=1&[email protected]) and ask. * The words France and Le Creuset will be on the piece somewhere. * Whatever mystery letters are in that rectangle will be hard/impossible to discern. * The screw for the knob will be slightly recessed and suitable for a blade screwdriver, not a Phillips. * Rack marks will be visible.
What will all modern Le Creuset pieces have?
* Gray speckled cast iron, not black. (photo 6) * Proper fonts and letter spacing. * Clear indications (see above) that it is a Traditional piece or a Signature piece, not a mish-mash of characteristics, like indented letters but thick rings. * If a box is present or sticker is on the piece, the specs will match the piece. A common red flag is the color code. * The weight will match the specs (fakes are usually heavier). I have found Williams-Sonoma's website is the most consistent about listing a piece's weight. You could also weigh it and ask someone the weight of theirs, or email Le Creuset to ask.
The best way to ensure your piece is real and is covered under the warranty is to buy from an authorized retailer. For all else, buyer beware. I hope you find this useful. Please feel free to point people to this pinned post.





