RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/Malazan • … • u/rianwithaneye

Mike Judge quote that has helped me understand why I love Erikson's writing so much

I was listening to an interview with Mike Judge (Office Space, King of the Hill, Beavis and Butthead, Silicon Valley, etc) and he said something that resonated with me and immediately made me think of the storytelling style of MBotF. He said that one of the hallmarks of bad dialog is when the only reasonable response of one character to another - in the real world - would be "***yeah, I know. I work here.***" Anytime he feels like that's what he would say in response to a line he's written he knows that he needs to dig deeper and find a more contextual and natural way to convey that information.

I've always hated dialog that very transparently only exists to explain details to the audience that would have been plainly obvious to the characters and would require no explanation whatsoever if those people were talking in real life. It immediately pulls me out of the story and gives me a sense of authorial intrusion. Any line that begins with "are you telling me that..." is usually a flagrant example of this and often amounts to outright insulting the audience's intelligence at the expense of genuinely good contextual exposition. A lot of authors handle this by making a main character a "fish out of water" who reasonably need everything explained to them, and even this device is often executed in a hacky way that feels obvious and clunky.

I think one of the many reasons GotM reached out of the pages and grabbed my attention so quickly both times I read it is that Erikson refuses to do that; he lets details trickle out in exactly the way they would if we were listening to a conversation between informed people with shared knowledge of the subject being discussed. When combined with the incredible depth of the world that Erikson and ICE created in their tabletop RPG campaigns it has made Malazan/Wu feel more like a real place than anything else I've ever read.

— 0