RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/MaliciousCompliance • … • u/evoblade

I hope you really enjoy calculations

A recent post about calculations reminded me of my time as a Construction Inspector. I was working this job during the summer between my junior and senior years of college, where I was getting a mechanical engineering degree. We mostly measured work that was being completed to authorize payment to contractors, as they were paid by unit of work performed, such as square foot of grass planted or linear feet of guardrail installed.

A more senior inspector and I measured some grass that was planted on a little median island along a road. It was roughly triangular, with two concave sides and rounded edges. It looked like [this](https://i.imgur.com/YROvFKv.png)

In our estimation we could approximate the area as triangle and it was gonna be really close. We performed the measurements and I turned in my calculation as a part of the paperwork. The boss later came up to me and told me that a triangle was not gonna cut it and we had to do it again.

*AW HELL NAW*

One of the really important things you learn in engineering is when to approximate and when you need to be very precise. In my opinion (and my very senior co-worker's as well), this was a waste of resources, but we did it anyway.

We measured the hell out of that little island of grass. I pulled out my [Machinery's Handbook](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Machinery's_Handbook) and went to town with parts of circles, chords.... the works. By the end, I spent four hours (on overtime) writing up 12 pages of neat calculations and diagrams to figure out the exact square foot area of that little patch (with six significant digits used in all calculations).

The next morning I handed him my stack of calculations. He looked through it for about 5 minutes and then said we were free to approximate as we saw fit in the future. The super duper precise total and our first stab at it differed by 0.02 square feet.

**TL;DR:** Question an engineer's judgement and demand more precision, and you will get more precision than you can possibly use.

Edit: I just remembered something, the calculation error may or may not have been in the state’s favor. So they paid me about $100 (gross) to either save or cost $0.10.

— 0