AC "Black Death" just 632 km after an engine overheating repair. Need technical advice on flushing safety and root cause.
Hey everyone,
I need some technical validation regarding a catastrophic HVAC loop failure on a 2021 Kia Sonet Petrol (23,000 km). The authorized workshop has diagnosed AC "Black Death" (mechanical compressor disintegration resulting in thick, metallic black sludge throughout the loop).
The vehicle's recent history raises significant diagnostic flags, and I want to verify if the dealer's proposed repair method is technically sound or a shortcut that will cause a rapid recurrence.
The Technical Context:
• February 2026: The vehicle was brought to the workshop with an "AC Not Working" complaint. The workshop diagnosed a severe engine overheating issue. They replaced the engine oil cooler and thermostat under warranty. (Note: An initial proposal for an evaporator coil cleaning was ultimately removed from the final job card, meaning the internal HVAC components were never cleaned or internally pressure-tested at delivery).
• October 2026: Just 632 km of driving later, the AC completely failed, leading to the current "Black Death" diagnosis.
The Proposed Repair Blueprint:
The workshop intends to replace the core components:
1. Compressor Assembly
2. Condenser Assembly
3. Evaporator Assembly
4. Heater Core (Note: The heater core runs on the engine coolant loop, which was the loop that overheated in February).
For the solid aluminum connecting lines and flexible rubber hoses, the workshop states they will simply perform a "chemical flush" and reuse them.
Technical Questions for HVAC Engineers & Mechanics:
1. Can a standard chemical flush reliably clean lines after Black Death? Given that the compressor suffered a structural metal-on-metal blowout, is a chemical flush capable of removing microscopic iron filings and baked-on acidic sludge from the inner walls of the lines? Or will residual debris inevitably dislodge and destroy the brand-new compressor shortly after installation? Should the lines be replaced completely?
2. Is a mechanical compressor blowout physically possible in just 632 km? Can "Black Death" fully develop within 632 km of normal driving, or is it an engineering certainty that the compressor was fatally compromised by the extreme thermal stress of the February engine overheating episode?
3. Why would the heater core require replacement alongside the AC loop? Since the heater core handles engine coolant rather than refrigerant gas, does its contamination/failure point to a botched coolant loop flush or cross-contamination from the original February overheating failure?
I have halted all work and requested an independent technical assessment from the manufacturer's regional office. I would appreciate your insights on these specific engineering points to help ensure a proper, long-lasting repair. Thanks!