RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/NBATalk • … • u/iCE_P0W3R

I need a sanity check: is it crazy to consider LeBron's 2008-2009 season the greatest single year peak in NBA history?

Disclaimer at the top: this is my opinion. I'm not asking if you agree, necessarily, I'm just looking to see if other people think the argument I'm about to present is reasonable.

The off-season is in full swing at my house, so, for the past two days, I've been pondering all-time NBA peaks and making lists. I made two separate all-time peaks list, one for single-seasons, and one for 3-year stretches (both are postseason inclusive). Well, more accurately, I've made the list for 3-year peaks, but I've been contemplating who I should put at the top of the 1-year list most of the day.

So that you get a feel for how I'm making this list and why I've been struggling, in descending order, here's my top 5 3-year peaks: 1971-1973 Kareem, 1966-1968 Wilt, 2000-2002 Shaq, 2012-2014 LeBron, 1991-1993 MJ.

You might notice that these 3-season runs are, generally speaking, the most successful stretch of these players careers. While I don't think it necessarily boils down to JUST rings, I do think that is at least a factor worth considering, and, further, that these players at their peaks will almost certainly guarantee one ring,

Now, here's my top 5 single-seasons ever, descending order; '94 Hakeem, 2000 Shaq, 1967 Wilt, 1991 MJ, 2009 LeBron.

Not only is LBJ the only player on this list to not have a ring during the named season, he didn't even MAKE the Finals that year! Further, if we're being honest, 2009 LeBron is not a terribly polished player, at least on offense. His post game is lacking, and his jump shot is kinda streaky. And yet, I can't help but think that, in spite of that, his combination of athleticism, court mapping, and unparalleled ability to get in the paint and score entitles him to that placement.

I'm going to be comparing LBJ during this season almost exclusively to 1991 MJ; I don't necessarily want this to be an MJ vs Bron post, I just think that, if it isn't this version of LeBron, frankly, then it almost certainly is MJ. I'm going to break this down into two sections. I will consider the regular season as equivalent to the playoffs and vice versa. In terms of a breakdown, for offense, I'm going to briefly discuss their skillsets, stats, and "offensive impact" before then moving towards playoff stats and "impact." Defense will be broader.

# Breakdown: '91 MJ

Speaking strictly in the context of the 1990's, MJ was about as complete a scorer as the league had ever seen. In the 80's, he had quickly developed a remarkable post-game and boasted arguably the greatest midrange jumper the league had ever seen. He was also a good foul baiter, and hit his free throws at a high clip. While those assets led to high scoring outings and even some playoff wins, the postseason offense with this less refined version of Jordan was somewhat middling, especially when you consider how high his ppg sometimes was. Entering the '90-91 season, however, Jordan famously bulked up and honed his ability to finish around the rim through difficult contests. Now, at last, you had a guard who really \*could\* score from anywhere on the court. Now, instead of just a great transition scorer, you had one of the premier transition threats in league history. Finally, instead of ranking 5th in the regular season in ORTG and in the middle of the pack during the playoffs, the Bulls were the clear-cut and obvious best offense the NBA had to offer, having a relative ORTG of +6.7 in the regular season and +6.3 in the playoffs.

Jordan was really a shot-maker and creator like the league had never seen. While people often marvel at his athleticism, MJ was also incredibly smart; he minimized turnovers, carefully picked the spots in which he'd take his shots, and he was an excellent passer (even if the assist numbers don't communicate that directly). While his stats pop off the page, like a league leading 31.5 ppg alongside 5.5 assists and 60 TS%, what impresses me more is the relative offensive rating. +1 or below is mid, anything about 3 is good, above 4 is elite, and, in the case of Jordan's Bulls, 6 and above is outstanding. In particular, what impresses me so much about this is that this is the worst offensive supporting cast MJ has until 1998, and yet it's arguably the best complete season of offensive basketball the Bulls play the entire decade. That's in large part due to their playoff performance, given they THROTTLE every opponent they face, with MJ putting up largely similar stats in the playoffs (a few more assists though). This season is 100% a *very strong* contender to be the greatest single season of offense any individual player has ever played.

His defense was excellent as well, as he had active hands and ridiculous speed, both of which were effective tools to force steals, whether that be on- or off-ball. Further, he is one of the best shot-blocking guards to ever walk on a basketball court, as he used his height and size to bully smaller guards on the perimeter. The Bulls were excellent defensively, 7th out of 27 in the regular season, and 1st in the playoffs. Now, I will stipulate that Pippen does have an argument to be an equivalent, if not better, defender, but I think for this particular season, they are mostly on a similar level. Pippen was better in terms of man-to-man defense, and definitely more versatile, but MJ was quite a threat to intercept perimeter passes. In any event, his two-way impact is undeniable, which makes this season a strong contender to be the best ever.

# Breakdown: '09 Bron

What *this version* of LeBron lacks in terms of a diverse scoring arsenal he makes up for with transcendental athleticism and high basketball IQ. His post game was middling, sure, and his jumper wasn't exactly elite, and yet, his ability to get to the rim and score around the rim was rivaled only by prime Shaq. 43% of his 2s were 3 feet or less from the basket, which he successfully converted 74.5% time. The rim-finishing he offered elevated the other tools in his kit, as well as each and every one of his teammates. This is only emphasized further by his brilliant passing, which was equal parts tricky and smart, and served to directly capitalize on the shots he created for his teammates. While I hesitate to say he was outright the best passer in the league (Nash and Paul were in the league), his combination of passing and scoring prowess made him an offensive threat like never before, particularly in transition. LeBron might be the greatest offensive transition threat ever, as he had the luxury of choosing between speeding towards the basket like fucking rocket or passing it to a wide open teammate when defenders inevitably coalesced around him. In terms of stats, Bron averaged 28.4 ppg with 7 assists on 59 TS%. While the relative offensive rating for the Cavs in the regular season isn't as pronounced as the '91 Bulls (it was +4.1), I think the fact that Cleveland was this good offensively despite a lack of surrounding star power or an all-time great head coach like Phil Jackson is certainly very impressive.

Defensively, there was no question who the best defender on the Cavaliers was in 2009. Prime LeBron is one of maybe a dozen players ever who can boast they can reliably defend all 5 positions. His unique combination of speed, strength, and size allowed him to both push around smaller guards while using his speed to show up slower bigs. It's also no secret that LeBron is an all-time great transition defender, if only because he practically trademarked the chase-down block; one of the most valuable defensive plays in basketball. As such, the Cavs were the 3rd best defense in the league and 1st in the playoffs.

Speaking of playoffs, I'm not sure how or why this happened, but LeBron cranked his offense all the way up to 11 come postseason, putting up an insane 35.3 points per game on 62 TS%, while the Cavs relative ORTG jumped to +4.9. In the ECF, against the Orlando Magic, easily the best defense either '09 Bron or '91 Jordan faced in the playoffs, LeBron put up an astounding 38.5 ppg with 8 assists on 59 TS%. If all else was equal, LeBron's continued dominance against a 59-win Magic team and prime Dwight Howard, I'd have few, if any, qualms about chalking up the disparity in rORTG across the regular season and playoffs to the idea that Jordan had better teammates and coaching.

# The value of a championship

...but all else is *not* equal. While I would maintain that Bron was the best player on the court during that series, the fact is that the Magic beat the Cavs in 6, directly denying James the chance to face off against Kobe in the Finals. And that's my issue. Listen, I can accept that the best player alive wasn't able to win a championship. Orlando was a great team, a little deeper in regards to talent, and wayyyyy ahead of the curve regarding the 3-point shot (I also think they're the ones who pioneered the Gortat screen, but I don't remember exactly if that's true). However, it's a much tougher bullet to bite that the best player season a player EVER had didn't end in a championship. At the same time, it's hard for me to look at the Cavaliers' 2009 season and not marvel at how far they came and chock them coming up short to just a lack of relative support around their respective star. I certainly don't think it's a stretch to say that '09 LeBron was comparably good to '91 MJ on offense, and I definitely think James was the superior defender, but again, saying that the best complete season ever didn't result in a win feels wrong somehow.

I want input on my thoughts here. Frankly, writing this has made me reconsider putting Jordan at the top (which was honestly my first choice to begin with). I still want to know what other people think, like if I picked the right season for these two GOATs, or if my reasoning is stupid and lame. I really just want to know what other people think on this front.

— 0