RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/NYGiants • … • u/Nooyorkgiant

Why I Think Taking a Wr in the First Round Is a Bad Idea

I think we all agree that this team needs a big playmaker. However, I think taking a receiver in the first round is ill advised. Didn’t we learn after the Reese years that taking skill position players in the first round is a silly idea (unless you’re a team like the chiefs drafting at the end of the round after a deep playoff run)? There’s a reason we draft in or near the top ten every year - we have numerous holes on this team. Taking a skill player is a luxury for a team that is a piece or two away, and is silly for other teams. In order to build a perennial contender, you need to continue to build from the inside out. That doesn’t mean drafting a left tackle in 2019 then abandoning that mentality. KEEP BUILDING THE CORE!!! The best teams in the league not only have strong O and D lines, but they’re DEEP at those positions.

Now, I’m not saying take a left tackle first round. But I do think that a player like Micah Parsons would help strengthen the core of this team far more than a receiver would. I know he’s an outside linebacker so it depends on what your definition of “skill player” is. But strong linebacker play, especially when the backer can get to the passer, is essential in the NFL. It should not matter at all that we have Blake out there, and Tae crowder who had an above average season for a 7th rounder. Parsons would not only be an enormous upgrade over Crowder, but then you’d have an elite LB tandem in Martinez and Parsons, and a DEEP LB group with Crowder rotating in. Building on strengths is a good thing!!! It’s the same mentality we’ve taken with the interior D line - look how that turned out.

Additionally, an efficient WR can much more easily be found in free agency/second round.

We are not good enough to be drafting skill players in the first round - see what happened with Odell, Engram, and even Saquon. Incredible players (two of those three) but maybe not the best choices for building a roster. CONTINUE TO STRENGTHEN THE CORE!!!

— 0