RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/Narnia • … • u/Fire_Fox1999

Where do the Telmarines come from? A possible answer.

Since there are quite a few posts about the Telmarines on this subreddit I decided to make my own. Here I'll try to answer the question asked in the title.

​

We know that thet Telmarines were pirates, they found an island in the pacific ocean and that island had a door to Narnia. We also know that Narnia existed since 1900, when Digory and Polly find it. So that means we need pirates in the Pacific after 1900.

The main problem is that the classic image of a pirate (like in pirates of the carribean) were long gone by the 1900, the golden age of piracy lies between 1650-1750, so long before Narnia. But not to worry! A form of piracy still exists (and continued to exist until 1945, the only reason it doesn't now is because there is no reason to), this form was called "Commerce Raiding". A practice between opposing sides in a war in order to hurt the other side's economy.

There were two wars in between the creation of Narnia and LWW (since Telmar already exists during LWW), these are the Russo-Japanese war (1905) and the First World War. The Russo-Japanese war did see commerce raiding in the Pacific by Russian cruisers (and sadly not by Japanese torpedoboats in the English channel) but they all came back or never went to islands. This leaves the only war being the First World War.

The Germans did do a lot of commerce raiding in both world wars, but only two ships did sail in the Pacific for any decent length of time. These were the converted cargo vessel SMS Cormoran and the sail ship SMS Seeadler. Of both ships, SMS Seeadler did by far the most islands in the pacific, had quite a few expeditions and eventually grounded herself on an island.

So if you'd ask me, the ancestors of the Telmarines were German sailors of the SMS Seeadler and they came to Narnia between 16 december 1916 and august 1917.

— 0