RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/Naruto • … • u/PithMango

movie spoilers - take Naruto's and Sakura's together...

...because is anyone clocking that making Naruto the nerd will shift Sakura's role on the team as the bookish smart one?

And that this means instead of focusing on Sakura's frankly groundbreaking positive relationship with a woman mentor, she's going to spend the whole time screaming at her mother?

I am not one to play around with spoilers, as they're usually full of bait and gimmicks.

But you have to see that "any change would be good for Sakura" is just about a basement-level take. Context. "Adding more girl" is not always the feminist solution when it comes to storytelling.

\*\*\* They're fixing the wrong thing, which is Sakura got a promising start to an engaging arc at least three times, and every time it came to nothing. The fillers treat her better.

Now, the other reason I discount spoilers is a storyteller can always go ahead and surprise us with a new twist. And marketing for movies has always been inane.

However I'm getting tired of the way this is being handled on our side as "just trust us bro" when taken together these are somewhat concerning directions. And they're acting like we should be excited about it.

While we're on it.... I'm also really leery that I can pick up a lot of idioms that are ripped out of fanfiction, and basically zero market research, which has conversations with test audiences. Like some dummy (or A.I. ugh) scraping an \*unfiltered\* fanfic category. I'm not the only one seeing that, right? Every fan knows better than to use fanfiction as a barometer for what people really want. A good quarter of fanfic writers are making things they \*don't\* want to see in canon.

And those Sakura idioms? Have hallmarks from a long line of OP self-inserts. It's a pretty dedicated sub-genre, with the popular ones clocking in at 100,000s of words. **By definition they don't care about balancing Team 7.**

And that's the biggest problem.

Specialty stories for tiny little niches can throw out Team 7 dynamics at will. That is the entire point of them! It's not that anything is good or better or worse as a story. It's that the movie has to begin and end with Team 7, with Dai-Nana-Han, or they are going to sink under their own weight. Different types of stories are just not doing the same thing.

To bring it back, are they going to let Naruto and Sakura compete academically? Or is this going to be one more Heroic Doe-Eyed Guy swooping in from afar and schooling the teacher, who is usually of an under-represented class? Or worse, merge Sakura's character with Ino's, and make Naruto look smart by dumbing her down? Like, how can so many of you be so sure this is a step up for her - I have questions. Let's see if this won't rob Sakura's characterization to build up their bait.

Oh, and if you still really want it live, then go watch Live Spectacle Naruto. To my mind if they can't beat the stage show, then they're wasting our time. It did change a lot of stuff, but mostly in compressing the story. There was plenty in there to get Naruto fans excited. And it started over ten years ago.

— 0