RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/NarutoPowerscaling • … • u/Aradjha_at

Meta: Konoha vs Pain

One thing that seems to be forgotten around here is when comparisons are being made, is the narrative. This came up as someone was vehemently arguing the case of Tsunade vs Kimimaro, where I eventually realized that the reason only Genin were sent on the Sasuke retrieval arc, is that if Kakashi or other jounins had been sent and been allowed to cut loose, the story would have ended differently. I'll use the Pain Arc as an example here.

Tsunade could not muster up a team, led by her and the ANBU, to fight Pain, because NARUTO needed to fight Pain. Alone, at his request. He could have gotten backup, from Sakura, from Shikamaru, or anyone stronger or more useful than them- but he would have won, as he was fairly close to winning on his own, and the fox wouldn't have come out.

For Naruto to fight Pain alone, Gai needed to be out of the village (No Gai/Kakashi teamup), Kakashi needed to die, Shikamaru and the other Konoha 11 needed to be unable or unwilling to fight, and Tsunade needed to be on heal/support/comms duty, which was brilliantly done, as the combined information of all the battles with the Pains also allowed for full understanding of their powers, instrumental to Naruto surviving the 6v1. Shounen villains are never killed off before their powers are revealed, so this was perfect. Tsunade also being on backup duty gave a plausible excuse for all fodder characters to survive and also allowed Pain to destroy the village with few casualties.

But IMO It was also to keep her from fighting and overwhelming Pain: nuking a village is one thing, but killing a team of powerful ninja that can heal, have full Intel, versatile skills, a battlefield commander, and comms is quite another.

So, the matchup: If Tsunade had been able to mount a team made primarily of herself, Kakashi and Gai, combining their abilities via Katsuyu telepathy, I think they could have defended the village without Naruto. By "Defend the village" here I mean defeat every Pain except for Deva Path and forcing him to flee into the range of Chibaku Tensei. Since mass battles in Naruto tended towards mooks being cut down by elites or summons, it would have been cool to see a Big fight of all the parents who are ninja or fighters putting their life on the line now that the village is destroyed and they have little left to lose. Could Pain best Tsunade, Kakashi and Guy? Could he beat them if Hisashi, Chouza, Shikaku, Genma, Anko and other named characters were there on support? What would happen if Inoichi's body possession landed on one of the Pains? Naturally, any of the defenders can die. To be onscreened by Pain rather than be forgotten or ruined by the sequel would be an honor to any of these braves.

Also, what was Kishi thinking when he decided that a single person should have the ability to make a small satellite. Truly the first of the Dragonball powers. It would have been better if it just multiplied gravity's effect on a person to such an extent that they couldn't move or were flattened.

— 0