The End of Ori and the Will of the Wisps, personal feelings and welcome discussion
Obviously, there will be spoilers in this post so if you haven't completed the game and want to remain spoiler free, please don't read on. I've marked the post appropriately, but still, here's another warning.
Also. This is going to be a long post. I literally can't shut the hell up so. Sorry in advance.
TDLR: I dislike the ending for a number of reasons and I'm also upset that I don't like it because it's the one thing I dislike about the entire series, and I hope a Definitive Edition-ish thing can add alternate endings to help me cope with this issue. Yes, I know that's unlikely and selfish but I have to think of something lol.
\~
Before I start to talk about the ending of this game, I feel like I have to start with how much I love this duo of games. I love Ori and the Blind Forest. It is the only metroidvania that I have enjoyed so much that I have completed it only to start it again immediately. It is one of my all time favorite games, with me having nearly no complaints that aren't inconsequential nitpicks. I don't know how to express that, for me, Ori and the Blind Forest is a unique and incredible experience for me -- and Ori and the Will of the Wisps is no different.
Obviously I wouldn't be here on reddit writing a novella about it if I didn't care.
Ori and the Will of the Wisps is a fantastic sequel. I said on my twitter that it's a sequel that really makes you appreciate its predecessor -- Ori and the Blind Forest is an even better game because it paved the way for Ori and the Will of the Wisps. I didn't really know what I wanted out of it but I can say I'm very satisfied. (I haven't really had much of the technically issues, personally. Some audio issues and some slow-down, one CTD, but otherwise good.)
I have buckets of praise for this game. The controls, the combat, the chase sequences, the score, the environments. I could wax poetic about it for ages. Aaaaaand...that's what really makes my strong dislike for the ending even more painful.
I'll freely admit that I'm a person who gets way too emotional about things. I have a lot of investment in this series and I have spent an exorbitant amount of time with it, so it's not really a surprise that the ending hit me as hard as it did. What surprised me was that I was, at first, perfectly accepting of the ending and only after a few hours of mulling it over did I actually have a cry about it.
I cried and oh boy was it ugly and embarrassing.
It took a while to settle -- both because of the content of the ending and the fact that I was disappointed that I was disappointed. I'd had such a fun time with the game that I actually felt bad that there was something I felt the need to "complain" about it. But often the only way for me to cope with stuff like this is to talk about it so. Here I am.
I'm glad to see that other people feel as baffled and disappointed as I do. I'm kind of speaking into the Reddit shaped void here but...let's get into it.
\~
**1) Ori evolving into a new Spirit Tree isn't a bad ending, it just isn't the one I wanted. And it isn't the one I wanted because it wasn't the one I felt the story was leading me to.**
Plenty of people have pointed out that Wisps follows the same general path as Forest. There are a lot of areas that are analogous to each other, and the story follows similar beats. Not necessarily a bad thing because there was enough new stuff to make it different, but what that also does is prime the player for those expected story beats. The ending is one of those beats -- Forest ended on a high note after much struggle. Ori's hardship was rewarded with a restored forest and a happy family. It's not unreasonable for us to believe that we're heading for that same end in Wisps.
**2) This end was apparently originally imagined for the end of Blind Forest**
There's an interview out there in which it's stated that this ending was intended for Ori and the Blind Forest, and it was only changed because the team realized the potential for the motherly bond between Naru and Kuro. Honestly, if the Spirit Tree ending had come at the end of Forest, it would have worked perfectly, in my opinion. It wouldn't have been nearly so traumatic, at least. But the problem is that now it feels like Moon Studios wasn't willing to consider other paths for Ori.
**3) This ending does not feel like a reward**
The addition of the NPCs and building quests were a welcome addition to me, but after the ending I can't help but to feel like it was a huge waste. I spent all this time exploring for Ore, befriending Mokis, working to restore Niwen not just to save Ku, but to make Niwen a haven for the inhabitants again. With Naru and Gumo sailing to Niwen, I was excited for the ending in which Ku was healed and the family was reunited, building a new life in the Glade of Niwen with the Moki and Gorlek. And the ending ripped all of that away. Yes, everyone is saved, but Ori is torn away from her family and is turned into a distant entity.
**4) There wasn't enough foreshadowing to prepare me for this ending**
The realization that Ori must become a new Tree only comes at the very end. Honestly, I didn't truly get it until the sprout was revealed, I wasn't completely sure what Seir meant by "you must grow". But even with a little more awareness, it isn't until just before the final battle with Shriek that it becomes obvious the endgame is Tree Ori.
**5) We spend the game working to heal Ku and then must immediately leave her.**
All this work and we don't even get a proper goodbye. After the sweet scene of their temporary reunion, I was so looking forward to Ori seeing Ku again after she's been healed. But we just...don't get any of that.
**6) The game hits you with emotional blows but doesn't give any indication that your sacrifice fixed it.**
We see that Niwen is recovering from the Decay, sure, but I guess I was hoping for more. The story beat with the Moki father and his family, seeing him return home to become stone with his wife and child, I was hoping beyond hope that the end game would see them living in that hut in the Glades after recovering from the Decay but. That kind of thing was also lacking.
**7) Shriek's lack of redemption feels out of place and almost cruel**
"Some people can't be saved" was not the message I was expecting from Moon Studios, especially after they made Kuro a sympathetic villain in a 30 second cutscene. And Kuro was arguably the worse villain -- her actions directly resulted in the decay of Nibel, but Shriek was born into the Decay and rejected because of it. It was shocking that Shriek wasn't redeemed and was left to die in the Silent Woods like that. Moon Studios doesn't hold back when it comes to the impact of character death but Shriek's treatment felt uncharacteristically cruel in comparison to the other adversaries we faced.
**8) There are so many other avenues that could have been taken**
I'm sure every player could come up with their own preferred ending. In relation to point 2, it just really, really feels like they came up with this idea, didn't use it for Blind Forest, and then felt like they had to use it for Wisps. And because of that it just...doesn't feel like it fits at all. Which is a real shame because, as I said, I don't think it's a bad ending. I just don't know if it was the right one.
**9) Here's to hoping...**
...that Moon Studios will consider adding alternate endings if they ever release a Definitive Edition of Will of the Wisps. The DE of OatBF added an entire area and tied up a lot of loose ends, so the precendent is there. I hope that we can get an alternate ending in which we can redeem Shriek, save Ku, restore Niwen, and Ori lives happily with her family in the Glades.
\~
I don't think I have anything else to say, finally. Thanks for reading!