RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/Parahumans • … • u/vention7

Why didn't Cauldron think to try this?

Why did Cauldron not think to use Amy to modify powers a-la Khepri, before Khepri happened?

There are a few reasons I can think of, but I'm not sure I'm entirely happy with any them.

Did they simply not know she could modify powers? I find that hard to believe due to how much they know about powers, and knowing what Amy’s power is. (And I know it's more like the removal of restrictions, but 'modify' gets the point across)

Did they not trust Amy to be stable enough to do it, the potentially many times it would be needed to “get it right”? That sounds like a fairly simple Contessa-solvable problem.

Did they not trust that the modified capes would be stable enough to use? This one is pretty fair, as Khepri wasn’t exactly ideal as far as side effects went. Loss of her ability to communicate and virtually all her personality and such being destroyed is pretty unhelpful if Cauldron wanted to be able to coordinate anything. But surely they would have seen many failures and just kept trying till Amy got it right? It’s not like Cauldron has any issue experimenting on people, they have a *lot* of failed experiments running about.

Did they think that the vials were a more cost effective/efficient way of trying to find better powers? I suppose that’s also possible, but then why not both? Use the vials to give people powers, then use Amy to modify/improve those powers if they seem like something that could help.

Did they not want to risk losing already strong capes to insanity? Fair, but then why not just use Amy on less inherently useful capes? And then if she perfects her method such that it avoids the mental breakdown involved, she can modify the more powerful capes too.

Does Amy’s modifications inherently result in the shard subsuming every aspect of the person from communication to personality, regardless of anything? This is the only one that *really* makes sense to me, but even then, I imagine Cauldron would have been grooming Amy well in advance of Scion going apocalyptic to use her on Capes during the fight. The capes would end up like Khepri, sure, but Cauldron wouldn’t mind.

— 0