RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/Pauper • … • u/No-Mango1315

Why Risk One of Pauper's Best Metas?

I can't understand some of the takes I'm reading in the threads about the Seeker/Bow combo.

I genuinely feel that we're, at least we were until last week, in one of the golden eras of Pauper.

The format diversity has been incredible. While the top of the meta is somewhat Aggro/Midrange-heavy, there is still a wide range of viable Combo and Control decks. There are meaningful choices, different playstyles are competitive, and the format has felt healthier than it has in years.

Yet a lot of people argue that it would be healthier to ban Snacker or unban a bunch of previously banned cards just to keep a brand-new two-card infinite combo around. One that slots naturally into historically powerful shells.

To me, the comparison seems pretty straightforward.

On one hand, you have a simple ban with consequences that are largely known. We already know what the format looks like without the combo because that's the format we've been playing for months: diverse, healthy, and widely praised.

On the other hand, you have bans or unbans that could completely reshape the format, for better or worse. Even then, there's no guarantee Seeker/Bow wouldn't still require action later if the data continues to confirm what the early results seem to suggest: the combo wins a lot, and the format is already beginning to warp around it.

So my question to those who oppose banning either Seeker or Bow is: why?

Why gamble with one of the best Pauper metagames we've had in years just to collect more data on a combo that already appears to be one of the strongest things you can be doing? What is the upside that outweighs the risk of destabilizing a format that, until this combo appeared, seemed to be in an excellent place?

— 0