RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/PersonalFinanceCanada • … • u/Dragynfyre

Overzealous use of "house poor" on this sub?

So a lot of the hot topics on this sub seem to be in regards to mortgages and budgeting around that. However, it seems a lot of people just look at a high mortgage payment and claim house poor without any nuance. I think a lot of people are applying the 30% rule but that can be shown to not work in a simple example:

Household A:

* Take home 3K/month * Mortgage + utilities + maintennance + insurance 1K/month

Household B:

* Take home 10K/month * Mortgage + utilities + maintennance + insurance 6K/month

Now the 30% rule is usually based on gross income but I see a lot of people basing it on take home so I'm making household A extra safe under the rule of thumb.

Many people will say household A is not house poor while they will say household B is house poor. This does not make sense as household A actually has half the money of household B after housing expenses. Other expenses like food and transportation don't increase just because income goes up. Household B could easily live on the same food and transportation as household A. Therefore, if household A is not house poor then household B shouldn't be house poor either while maintaining at least the some standard of living as household A.

There's one argument that kind of makes sense which is the risk of income reduction is higher at high incomes than low incomes but taking that argument to its logicial conclusion it would imply no one should buy a home over Y amount regardless of income where Y is property that can be supported on a minimum wage income.

EDIT: I'm talking more about the people who are responding to questions of people asking if they are house poor and not talking about the people who make the original post.

— 0