RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/PixelArt • … • u/DarkEater77

Which of those two has the best shadow?

Hi, everyone !!! i'm trying to make different icons. My Play button is done, with a shadow under the arrow. Wanted to keep that for other icons, and here are my 2 tries for Music. Difference is the far right shadow.

My problem, is that i can't seem to be happy with any... Am i missing something?Or am i thinking too much?

— 0