Antisemites belong on a cross and will be purged from this community.
Salvete omnes. We need to talk.
Every single fucking post about Hadrian and the Bar-Kochba Revolt on this sub brings out absolutely vile comments by people who go beyond the Roman LARP to justify the history of antisemitic violence throughout European and Mediterranean history. Unironic comments about how Jews deserved it as Christ-killers or as Judeo-Bolshevists appear _reliably_. This is unacceptable and really shameful for those of us who are into Roman history for the excitement and complexity of it rather than as an outlet for just being a malding angry racist snowflake. If you wonder why Romaboos have a bad rep sometimes, this is why and it fucking needs to be addressed. We’re one of the biggest Roman-themed communities on Reddit and a major source of export for Roman-themed content elsewhere on the web. So even when shitposting, have some basic standards.
Hadrian’s empire-wide persecution of Jews was an exception rather than the rule of Roman history and followed very specifically in the wake of the Bar-Kochba rebellion. In fact, Judaism with its ancient traditions had often up to that point been fascinating to Romans. Monotheistic Jews at the Temple in Jerusalem prior to its destruction in the Great Jewish Revolt had been given essentially an exception to the rule that local temples had to pay homage to the emperor instead being simply allowed to pray on the emperor’s behalf. In fact, one of the oldest continuous Jewish communities in the world today is that of the city of Rome where there was a Jewish presence even prior to Pompey’s conquest of Judea because in the heavily international and intercultural environment of the Hellenistic-period Mediterranean, immigrant communities were often prominent in the major cities of the ancient world, as they are today (in fact, Ptolemaic and Roman Alexandria was really the intellectual center for ancient Judaism where Jews at one point made up some 40% of the city’s population and participated in its scholarship as was the case of the Jewish philosopher Philo). In fact, many in Rome itself would either convert to Judaism or more commonly become what were known as “God-fearers,” Gentiles who never fully converted to Judaism (circumcision and whatnot) but nevertheless took interest in monotheism and the Hebrew Bible, sometimes taking part in Jewish festivals. All this to say that if you are trying to use the Roman Empire and Roman culture to model your hateful spam of ideas, you simply don’t understand the relationship they actually had with Judaism. And furthermore, none of the tropes of modern antisemitism from racialization to stereotypes about money to the role as Christ-killers were major issues on the minds of pagan Romans and what qualms some of them did have about Jews were simply part of the stereotype of exotic eastern decadence, the same prejudice applied to Greeks, Egyptians, Persians, and even early Christians, which themselves in their early centuries had heavy overlap with Jewish identity. So no, the Romans did not agree with you. They did not even have the idea of “western civilization” unless you mean literally just Roman civilization by it.
So let’s talk about the posts and comments. We have not been removing posts about Hadrian persecuting Jews because, well, that happened and in general these posts have not been advocating such actions today. But we do end up removing a lot of comments about how “the Jews have deceived the world” or whatever and banning people spitting antisemitic rhetoric. We’re sometimes slow to get to this simply because of how big the sub is (sorry) so I ultimately am not sure if people see a lot or a little of it but I promise that it is not policy to tolerate that sort of thing. Report and call it out. Regarding a particular video segment by the legendary Dovahhatty (may his name be honored) that gets posted a lot outside of the clearly satirical context of the full-length video it’s from, I am in favor of removing it in the future because it’s sus that that’s the only segment of the series that gets uploaded (in fact it was my first exposure to the series and gave me an unfairly negative opinion of him before I actually watched the series) and because the comments are always a mix of people being bothered and actual racists.
Let’s be better.
—Iacobus
TL;DR: title.
Edit: Another one of the mods pointed out that we also have Reddit’s ToS to follow so even if you don’t care who’s offended, if you like this community, you should really care about its being as this site will allow.