RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/Sekiro • … • u/Over-Magazine-3218

LMTSR has big combat design issues (it is trash)

This mod does not understand what made sekiro combat fun and fair.

Fairness of sekiro's combat rests on 5 principles: 1. An enemy needs to deflect your attack to start a combo (otherwise the telegraph of the combo lasts for at least 1-2 player attacks). Because of this, player have a clear indication that it is time for an enemy to attack. 2. A lot of enemy actions can be interrupted by a player's attack. So a player can be even more aggressive and find attack windows by the clever use of spacing and dodging. Also this prevents developers from creating unintuitive delayed attacks, for example. 3. The endings of enemy's combos is clearly telegraphed. An enemy will not enter an idle animation mid combo. So it is clear when it is time for a player to attack. 4. There is almost no bullshit like gang fights, status effects, summons, morgott-level delayed attacks, etc 5. Bosses give a player windows to heal

Sekiro's combat is fun mainly because of 2 things: 1. In the fight both an enemy and a player have more or less equal amount of time attacking. Hence they are both able to show all of their moveset. Also, the fight looks like two warriors of equal strenght are fighting, not just an underdog fighting against a god, but somehow winning. 2. Also enemies' average combos dont have more then 5 hits. And even the longest ones (genichiro's for example) have less then 10 hits. I dont think I need to explain why this is good.

LMTSR on the other hand breaks all of the rules above. You need to parry 15 hit combo (boss goes idle for a moment in the middle of it - dont even thing of attacking here), then you have a window to make 1-2 hits. Then again, another 15 hit combo. Btw, each hit in that combo damages for a half of your hp.

Whats interesting is that malenia follows most of the rules above. Hence she is the best (and the only good) boss of the ER.

— 0