Message to the Mods
Dear mods and admits of the [r/Shrek](r/Shrek) subreddit, ever since the Shrek 5 trailer released at the beginning of the week, the whole entire community has been absolutely flooded with posts and comments complaining about the new movie. And I don’t just mean people upset that the characters look different and more “cartoony” than the previous films, but actively engaging in unprofessional behaviour. Besides just those who have kept on saying copy and paste criticisms like “this doesn’t look like Shrek”, “it looks to much like Disney or Illumination”, “this looks like it was done with AI” or “they ruined my childhood”, or any of the other frankly childish ways of saying that they don’t like it, people have been straight up hostile towards those who say they don’t mind the looks of the characters or even that they are excited for the film.
Differing opinions is one thing, and people will keep saying they have every right to say what they say or that their criticisms are valid (which even then I think is a poor excuse for shutting down positive comments), but it’s a whole other thing to be insulting and downvoting into negative numbers those who say anything positive about the upcoming film.
Three whole days of having to come across thousands of comments and posts, of entitlement and gatekeeping, and getting into fights. I even had to block someone for accusing me of spreading toxic positivity and then start insulting me. We all know that Shrek is a cherished film series, and a new film made 16 years later after the fourth film was promoted as the final film, that happens to have a different artistic direction is a lot for people to handle, but the way the community has been reacting to it is absurd. What’s even more so is that people (STILL!) assume that Universal should pull a Sonic the Hedgehog situation and delay the movie and waste lots of time, money and resources to redesign all the characters and build new rigs just to make them happy. That whole thing with Sonic was a one-time incident and should not be the template for more online behaviors. The people who worked on this movie for several years clearly know what their doing, and it’s a massive, massive disservice to them to demand that their hard work be scrapped and redone, and even more so to say that they look like “AI”, something you should never say about a movie that was made by hand with thousands of talented people.
It really pains me to see a fandom for something that means a lot to me start to transform into something resembling the Star Wars fandom, which is notorious for entitlement, gatekeeping and harassments. And even more painful that the mods and admins don’t work harder to snuff out commenters that insult others just because they either like how the film looks or choose not to jump on the hate train. I seriously don’t know if the admins are that much or “free speech” people and will just the people here say anything the want no matter how heated and toxic it gets, or if they are just apathetic and are like Regina George in the movie Mean Girls where they actually enjoy watching everyone fighting each other like wild animals, to the tune of “World Burn” from the Broadway musical.
Shrek 5 is only a year away, so I really want to see this subreddit start to act more civil and have better communication with each other. We all love our favorite green ogre here, so let’s work harder to make this a safe environment to talk about the upcoming film, that doesn’t involve constantly being bitter and cynical to the point of throwing insults at one another. And for those of you who think I’m no better, please take a step back and think before you type.
And for those of you who think I’m trying to police people or tell them what to think, or that I’m doing the harassment, I’m autistic and it’s a force of habit of mine to go back and forth hoping that we will meet Halle way or even compromise and the other people will understand what I’m saying. I’m sorry, I’m truly sorry to everyone who’s been annoyed with my continuous replies. It’s never about controlling anyone, it’s about putting out the flames in the fires that is controversy.
Thanks, lots of love.