Are we focusing on the right things with bulk fermentation?
(Swipe for ingredients and process. Dough temp was 72-76 F throughout bulk.)
Reading "Secrets of Open Crumb" by Addie Roberts and "Open Crumb Mastery" by Trevor J. Wilson have started shifting my perspective on the process and are getting me closer to what I've been after. My most recent bake pictured here is probably the one I am the happiest with so far and it got me wondering about something I struggled with for a long time along the way:
"Is my dough over/underproofed" is probably the most common question on this sub, and I believe that the answer is very often "both," or at least it was in my case. I'll comment with an example picture of the bread that I mean might fit into this category.
The loaf has good height, good oven spring, dramatic ear, but it has a crumb that causes disagreement on whether its over or underproofed. Maybe there are some tight areas in the center but some ragged larger holes in other areas (NOT tunneling or caverns from severe underproofing, that's different). Maybe the crumb is dense throughout due to lack of CO2 production, but the gluten still lost structure and broke down in other areas.
I am beginning to believe that the reason comes down to the influence of these two things on bulk fermentation more than they are typically discussed:
1. Starter health:
* Starter that just has too much of one type of lactic acid bacteria can begin to break down the gluten in dough before the yeast has had a chance to do its thing. It's not *just* the acidity as is often mentioned, but which bacteria are dominating. * **This is at the core of what I mean when I say its possible for bread to be "both" (under and overproofed simultaneously):** * **The bacteria have gone too fast and caused signs of overproofing via early proteolysys/ gluten breakdown.** * **The yeast has gone too slow and caused signs of underproofing via not enough conversion of sugars or CO2 production.** * I have noticed that my doughs show signs of this whenever I don't give my starter enough care: if my starter smelled tangy *at* peak rather than yeasty-sweet, and especially if it had been in the fridge recently.
2. Dough development/ strength:
* Just a few months ago I was completely overdoing it β beating the hell out of my dough in a stand mixer until it felt like rubber. I was getting super tall and beautifully shaped loaves this way, but the crumb had a dense, slightly tough chew to it. Not what I wanted. Too much elasticity, not enough extensibility. * From there I started dialing it back, which meant experimenting with how I was actually building structure in the first place: * Longer autolyse gave me a head start on gluten development and produced a noticeably more extensible dough that responded better to folding. * Hand mixing instead of machine mixing forced me to actually feel what the dough was doing β when it started resisting, when it relaxed, when it was done. Not impossible with a mixer, but probably more difficult to feel. * Getting a feel for how the dough responds during folding can help determine if the dough has had too many folds (starting to resist a lot or feel rubbery) or it needs more folds (going slack, spreading in the container). * I also just started being as gentle as possible as not to degas my dough, especially when it got "proofy" as Trevor J. Wilson calls it. * For me, if it goes above a certain % rise and feels like a giant marshmallow, I quit preshaping altogether. * This relates to the first point because the correct amount of dough strength will allow for pushing bulk fermentation further before breakdown; it will give the yeast a longer chance to do their part before the acid interferes.
Why am I mentioning all this? Because perhaps the question we should be asking in A LOT of cases is not "should I have fermented longer/shorter." Perhaps the goal isn't to nail a fermentation time β it's to build a dough and starter that can actually handle full fermentation.
Anyone with more experience than me noticed anything similar? Am I on the right track to be thinking this way? I would always like to be as efficient as possible, so if I am overdoing it or wasting my time with anything I'd also like to know!