The Neclord arc: When I stopped taking Suikoden 1 seriously
I played suikoden 3 & 4 back when they came out and enjoyed them quite a bit. They certainly weren’t perfect but they were serviceable RPGs with a really cool gimmick they sort of delivered on. Last year I finally got around to suikoden 1 and while I knew it wasn’t as legendary as suikoden 2, for so long Id heard that the original 2 suikodens (and 5) were worlds better than the two I’d played. What I got was a pretty generic JRPG who’s only real draw was the same exact gimmicks as the ps2 games only on a much more basic level. The part that was arguably the best was the story which was debatably more cohesive and digestible than 3’s but I wouldn’t call it objectively better. Still I thought “whatever”, I was enjoying the game for what it was: and then the Neclord arc short circuited my brain with how out of place and poorly executed it was.
Problem 1) >!Neclords insane plot armor and abilities. Even if he’s meant to be the Dracula or Magus of this setting (which is quite a stretch) he’s given so many free abilities and defenses for one singular true rune and nothing he accomplishes is properly built up/justified through the story or demonstrated to come from cunning, talent or having been around for so long. He’s just that powerful because the writers were dead set on a specific style over substance scenario. For a character this influential you need more than one otherwise redundant flashback that happens *right after* *he’s introduced* to justify all the effort required to take him out.!<
Problem 2) >!The central conflict of the story is driven to a large degree by the devastating potential of the true soul eater rune and the last arc was punctuated by the fact that Teos death powered up the soul eater to the 2nd highest level it can reach in this game. This is the point in the story where a protagonist gets over confidant from the raw power they’ve unlocked and/or makes miscalculations while lost in a desire for vengeance, NOT the time to throw an antagonist that trivializes the runes existence. Even if he had been properly foreshadowed and built up to be the kind of character they want him to be: now is not the time to pit the player against an unkillable vampire.!<
Problem 3) >!Throughout the game we’ve had ample time to get to know Viktor, he’s almost been with the party as long as Teos entourage and while what’s been revealed is not entirely at odds with the inelegant lore dump dropped right before the unwinnable boss fight, based on that logic: Viktor should’ve recognized his handiwork at fort lorimar immediately **not** waiting until the warriors village people mention Neclord by *name* to freak out. Furthermore if we’re to take this backstory seriously he should at worst be a Supernatural style hunter if not closing in on being in league with the hunters from Castlevania. The fact that no skills like that have been demonstrated up till now other than being a competent swordsman with street smarts (which could be explained in a lot of ways) calls this backstory into question. At the bare minimum we should’ve seen him demonstrate far more knowledge of the supernatural than he has, and it should’ve come up that he is actively seeking a means to kill a very dangerous somebody, if not outright already know what the thing is and have a general idea of where to look for it.!<
Which leads into Problem 4) >!The true night rune is completely unearned. There is no journey of discovery or trial to acquire the means to kill Neclord: an old man conveniently just has it lying around in his back yard. The dungeon leading to the Night rune is generic and meaningless. Viktor does nothing to gain favor with it. The time travel makes no sense as a defensive curse cast by this rune specifically and the talking sword joins the team *because* **it’s** **BORED**! !<
I finished the game but nothing that happened after that really undid the damage it did to my perception of the story, characters or game design. I don’t really know how to spin this into a productive discussion. I just didn’t see anybody commenting on this and had to speak my frustration into the universe. I still intend to play Suikoden 2, even if my expectations are low, cause I have a digital copy already. I guess I do wonder whether Suikoden fans think this is a “Suikoden 1 isn’t the best, they get better” issue or a “this emblematic of suikodens lore, world building and character interactions so suikoden might not be your cup of tea” issue.