Suikoden 2: The Masterpiece That Convinced Me To Let Go Of The Franchise
A few months ago I made a vent thread about how Neclord's chapter disrupted the flow of suikoden 1 and while I got some deserved backlash for how I delivered that, some people were polite enough to ask my opinion when I played suikoden 2. This thread is the deposit for those thoughts. My Ultimate realization is that this franchise may never have been for me. On paper this game is much of what I want a JRPG to achieve with a large number of named characters (and even NPCs) giving life to the setting, multiple combat systems illustrating different perspectives on conflict that also help specific narrative beats pop and a wide variety of side activities to flesh out the world. Sadly the actually content of the story/world are not what I want at all.
Issue 1 Too strict of adherence to JRPG tropes
>!The game stars a silent protagonist, predestined to save a rag tag rebel alliance, against an evil empire, the rebal alliance was actually \*on par\* with the evil empire when the protagonist showed up but several contrivances are made during the first third of the story to ensure the player is the only hope, at the end you fight a demon/evil god and the enemy forces fortress collapses when the final boss is killed! While those tropes are not inherently bad, in this case I think they seriously undermine the more complicated themes the devs were trying to touch on. Of course that leads into!<
Issue 2 The morals they’re spewing are incredibly hard to swallow
>!It’s admirable the writers tried to convey the reality that the evil general being killed off isn’t enough to end the war both because of political momentum and because the causes of the war are deeper than one man. Having said that the central conceit of two friends trying to achieve the same thing on different sides of the war falls apart pretty quickly. Regardless of whatever the silent barely developed protagonists unvoiced goals were: I personally was never so pretentious as to believe I could “end war” in the region. That’s not how things work IRL and suikoden itself has shown time and again sentient beings are perpetually at war with themselves, each other or the true runes. Labeling a specific period in a specific region as being “a time of peace” doesn’t make all the injustice go away and Jowy/Silverburg using this “noble goal” as an excuse for the things they let happen or participated in is so naïve, arrogant and full of hubris words cannot describe my feelings. The nonsensical idea the writers have that anybody was “trying to minimalize casualties” after all the disingenuous feints at peace talks, the many things that happened in Muse or Silverburg releasing the beast rune out of what is clearly spite is both insulting and infuriating, especially given the degree to which Silverburg gets off scott free. At least Jowy has the decency to realize how screwed up his means were. Speaking of which.!<
Issue 3 I don’t like Jowy
>!I don’t dislike him per se, by the end I understood and begrudgingly respected how far he was willing to go to create a better future, but he’s an ally for barely a quarter of the game. He’s not in the party for the entirety of that and he acts blatantly sus for the latter portion of it. Furthermore instead of actually developing this friendship say back in the first game or using timeskips, once again near the end of our time with Jowy they just shove a flashback in our faces and tell (rather than show) us how to feel. Ultimately I never was so invested in the relationship with Jowy that I felt it was more meaningful than the friends we made along the way and certainly not so much that I felt satisfied with a wandering the earth carrying the burden of the true runes for countless years scenario, especially considering how little respect I have for the devs idea of the “peace” these two characters are sacrificing so much for. Frankly both characters deserved better and the fact that the devs spent the entire game doing nothing with Jillia until the last moment to turn around and make her a love interest exclusively to make it sting more when Jowy decides she and Pilika are better off without him in their lives is a special kind of forced tragic writing I have zero patience for. Which vaguely leads into the final issue!<
Issue 4 true runes and fate.
>!I don’t have a lot of respect for any writer who uses unavoidable destiny as a part of their story. The fact that reconciliation must come *after* conflict between the two friends even in the “good” ending and they have neither the option to live within their roles as the sword/shield while knowingly/intentionally working together in secret (thus potentially mitigating some of the tragic fates that appear to happen in a casual playthrough think Nanami faking her death on a grander scale in the good ending) or openly working together on the same side against the tragic “fate” Leknat and the true runes have determined for them, is both really boring and not nearly as deep as the writers are pretending it is. Meanwhile I just kind of hate the true runes they’re really not that interesting as fundamental forces of the universe, semi sentient beings meant to insight conflict or especially as a power system. When Neclord takes three different factions using different mechanics to kill, Luca Blight who isn’t even a true rune user takes three team fights and a rainstorm of arrows but Nanami nearly dies having to protect the protagonist/jowy from a tiny group of regular archers I have absolutely zero suspension of disbelief left to give. The rules are made up and the points do NOT matter.!<
OK 1 last complaint. War battles are hot scripted garbage and this fanbase needs to have a serious conversation about not mentioning them as a point in favor of the game.
Now before you donwvote me into oblivion, can I at least say some nice things?
Hot dang the pixal art is a technical and aesthetic achievement, I have never seen so many variations of sprites or so thorough a utilization of even the most basic of sprite poses to effectively convey so many real life character interactions. Stuff like the cute head tilt when a character sitting down looks sideways, the fact that clouds/birds will periodically pass overhead on the world map \*and\* generate shadows, flipping sprites when they’re in bed to look like they’re sleeping on their stomach (or walk back and forth behind a blanket sprite layer to look like they're tossing and turning) and the way the sprites are drawn in such a way that the camera can shift angles and pan during fights, really make this world feel alive. If the plot was even a little bit more palatable I would be onboard with the whole “this game is a masterpiece” train because again…Hot Dang!
Story beats I actually like:
>!Nanami is both an adorable cinnamon roll and a cool big sis. Her breaking out of prison and being seconds away from rescuing the boys without the mercenaries help is hilarious and awesome. By the end of the game I never wanted to see Viktor/Flik ever again but early on them acting like responsible adults and being outraged at Muse using Jowy and Protag as child soldiers was the kind of moment this game desperately needed more of. Waiting for Jowy through the sunset/sleeping under a tree on a hill after the fall of muse were both powerful moments. Richmond was one of my favorite minor characters and him replacing Shus coin was a neat twist. There haven’t been a lot of moments with this franchise where I was personally invested in characters continuing to appear from game to game but there was a moment when I recruited Yoshino where I put the dots together “husband wears eyeglasses, wife wearing miko dress and uses a nagata…OMG these are Sanae’s parents”! Likewise seeing Futch find baby bright in an optional side story was a very nice sidequest.!<
Mechanically, there are quite a few positives. The primary gameplay loop of the franchise is arguably most effective here with a good level of freedom once the story finally gets rolling, a run button and snappy load times it’s the most fun to go double check towns for fresh faces and the trade shop for a good deal. The farm adds some fairly unique collectables you can go looking for and the cooking competitions that supports are a nice waste of time. The climbing mini game is one of the best minigames in the franchise and one of the few reasons I would consider playing this again. Finally duels as always are a highlight of the franchise and it’s a shame there aren’t more of them.
Finally there are some pretty good musical pieces. I liked Rescue, A Peaceful Mountain Village, Those Who Work Must Eat, Dandy Richmond, Fugue Praise Be My Master, Nahala Yam Koom, We Are Number Woof, Everyday is a Carnival, Secret Village of the Ninja and Gothic Neclord (shout out to the guys who brought it up in the Necklord thread, yes his theme is in fact the only good thing about him). However Beautiful Morning beats them all. Seriously this song is Christmas morning and lazy Sunday afternoons in music form, again if the story was slightly more palatable I would be on the master piece train because this song just makes me feel happy.
TL; DR Suikoden 2 is an ambitious game from an era when devs were constantly pushing the limits of hardware/game design and it’s competently designed delivering on a decent amount of content, but between my dislike for the story and the fact that it’s a jack of all trades master of none I’m not overly fond of anything it does and I think in general the series never lived up to the vision of what I want of a JRPG.