RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/TheBoys • … • u/Burk_Bingus

Did anyone else find it completely unsatisfying that... [Season 5 Episode 3 Spoilers]

>!They didn't kill off Ryan in episode 3? The trailers for this season built up this scene as some pivotal gut-punch moment but in the end it just kind of fizzled out when they show him still alive. We are almost halfway through the final season which should be a bloodbath but it feels like the writers are too scared to commit to anything remotely controversial and we are just getting the same old fakeouts with no consequence.!<

>!This should've been the perfect scene to simultaneously establish how low both Homelander and Butcher have sunk, and that Homelander has completely committed to his ideals of becoming an immortal god. We already know that Homelander is evil and depraved enough to beat the shit out of his own kid, this scene tells us nothing we don't already know. It would be so much more impactful that he is willing to murder his own child. Butcher being willing to gaslight and send Ryan to his death would hit so much harder if he actually died.!<

>!I also don't think it really makes sense with Homelander's character that he leaves Ryan alive here. His dialogue in this scene is about him realizing that Ryan was always just a means for him to extend his own legacy and that he no longer cares about Ryan. After all Ryan has been missing for how long and Homelander hasn't bothered looking for him? Ryan is nothing but a threat to him now, why wouldn't he eliminate him?!<

>!Obviously Homelander is able to detect if Ryan is still alive by his heartbeat, so I don't really buy the explanation that Homelander mistakenly left him alive either. Not to mention Homelander's usual MO is to kill people in far more decisive fashion. They even show Homelander hesitating before delivering the final sickening, crunching punch, yet the writers then immediately walk this back as having no actual consequence. This scene would've been great if they actually committed to Ryan'a death here. Instead it just felt like lazy Disney writing to me.!<

— 0