RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/TheDarkTower • … • u/AlphaTrion_ow

Brief Analysis: Some foreshadowing on the main characters [SPOILERS BOOKS 1-7]

I think I just spotted an element of foreshadowing on which main characters make it all the way to the ending of the story, and which do not: **The degree to which they have cut the ties with their old life before meeting Roland.**

The central point is that if a member of the ka-tet has completely cut themselves off from their old life (and therefore thrown their lot in with Roland's in full), then they die.

* **Eddie:** He had nothing left back in his New York. His brother Henry was the last thing he cared about. He had no family, no friends, no home, no job, no future and no life. There were only two things that held him there after Henry's death. One was the forceful grasp of Balazar's gang, and Eddie was happy that Roland freed him from that. The other was his cocaine addiction, which he did bring with him to Mid-World, but that he conquered soon after through necessity. * **Jake:** He was a forgotten child from neglectful parents in the anonymous crowds of New York. His parents offloaded him to the housekeeper and barely interacted with him at all. He did not stand out at school, having no real friends and was easily ignored. His teacher, upon reading his deranged essay, failed to see that he was going through a mental breakdown. The housekeeper (Greta Shaw) was the only genuinely warm and loving relationship he had all his life, but even she distanced herself from him - after realizing that he viewed her as his mother. By the time we see him in Book 3, he has emotionally checked out from everything and everyone, and he regains his innocence upon being reunited with Roland. * **Oy:** He was outcast and chased off by his pack (or whatever the collective noun for billy-bumblers is), because he spoke like a human too much, and he was left in the wilderness to die of starvation when he joined the ka-tet. (We learn this from a short chapter in Book 7 that is written from his point of view.) Oy never had anything to return to since his first appearance in the books. * **Father Callahan:** He had lost his connection to his old life many times over. In fact, he appears to have a self-destructive streak - fueled by his alcoholism and crisis of faith - that makes him constantly uprooting himself whenever he settles down anywhere - in between long spells of vagrancy across America. By the time he is introduced in Book 5, he has settled down once again, but is willing to leave with Roland with barely a second thought for the Calla-folk. Callahan does not belong anywhere any longer.

While these characters may form bonds with each other (Eddie and Susannah, Jake and Oy), this still leaves them adrift in Roland's orbit, as there is no other fate that calls them than Roland's.

There is only one exception:

* **Susannah:** She was initially lost herself, with not even a place in her own mind that she could call her own. She was trapped between Odetta and Detta without even realizing it. Odetta was a vapid socialite who could hobnob with many people, but could never move past vapid pleasantries, and Detta was a sociopath who never wanted any relationships at all and only cared about her own amusement. She had lost her parents, and inherited their money, but had no use for it; Detta even went shoplifting for the thrill. She was left to her own devices with nobody looking out for her. This was when Roland took her through the Door. And her new dominant identity, Susannah Dean, was not born until after she had been in Mid-World for a while.

And yet...

Susannah had one last thing tying her to her New York, one last connection that was never severed: her godfather "Daddy Mose", **Moses Carver**.

Despite Moses not being a big presence in her life pre-Roland, she remembers him with fondness from her childhood even while in Mid-World, and we learn later on that he still remembers her with love. Even though she never meets him again, there is a small tug at her heart when Roland does, presumably through a small remnant of ka still connecting them by that point. (I am unsure if it is her freshly severed bond with Roland, or the old and faint bond she had with Moses that made her sense the encounter.)

My point is that Susannah, despite having little to return to, never completely gave up New York life for the Tower, which is why ka could ultimately pull her back to some version of New York. One that had echoes of the new bonds she had formed while in Mid-World, and that erased her gunslinger memories. Even though her fate felt to me like a cheap consolation prize, it was a better outcome for her than to be eaten alive by a feverish and hunger-crazed Mordred the next night, or to be blasted to pieces by a sneetch from the Crimson King one day later. Which is surely what would have happened to her if part of her had not wanted to return to New York.

— 0