THEY MADE MONEY: Here's How asset flips make money...The Day Before is no exception.
Here's how asset flipping scams, like the Day Before is theorized to be, actually work:
I start a company as an unaffiliated entity of one of my other companies. I use that company as the operating company for my game development and release.
I lend myself through my unaffiliated entity (as senior debt) several million bucks (i.e., from one of my other legal entities, say for example, a different game development company that I still have, or a very good friend has).
Money doesn't even have to change hands. I can ascribe the debt to services in kind (such as huge management fees, and other consulting fees which have secured payment terms because my new company has no money to pay for them yet).
I secure that debt with a first position lien, so I have priority on any disbursements that the company makes. (My debt gets paid first over any other debt or investor obligation).
I then buy some assets and spend minimal money making some kind of launchable product that will survive the 2 hour refund window on Steam, and launch it.
I can then close the studio. I make sure the debt is big enough that there is no money left after the debt is paid for anyone else from any and all cash receipts. Any money the entity collects, even during bankruptcy, goes to paying senior debt first. Every time. That's the law. Additionally, me posting that I closed the studio does not mean that I even necessarily filed for bankruptcy. I simply just post on Twitter and keep the entity open until Steam pay.
Even if I do go bankrupt for some reason, bankruptcy does not absolve vendors from paying (including Steam). Especially if it's a re-org (Chapter 11 style). So Steam still has to pay out to the insolvent development entity on every non-refunded purchase of this game. This is why people are still shilling for this game so hard. Because it'll keep people playing.
Receivers/liquidators go after non paying vendors very hard. They collect by any means necessary. What is the receiver/liquidator? A third-party appointed entity who is tasked with liquidating the entity and paying all cash out to stakeholders in order of priority.
Who gets to appoint the receivior/liquidator you might ask??? I do, as the largest 1st position debt holder against the legal entity. I get to liquidate my own company effectively with a friendly receiver.
I get to make sure that Steam is chased down for the money. Steam is a vendor. It's a sales platform. It owes these guys money and will pay it to the insolvent operating entity.
That operating entity by the laws of bankruptcy must then pay the first position debt to its legally unaffiliated (but actually affiliated parent) over any and all other debt.
The fact of the matter is, this game was made up of no more than 6 months of very limited development, about 20k of assets, 100k at most of marketing and a 50k time square ad. This game will have made the owners at least 3 - 4 million, that they'll still get paid unless everyone refunds this bag of ass and Steam enables that (which they won't).
Then there's leg 2 of the scam: Investors. If I get lucky and my ads go viral, I can then raise investor money as equity. Equity that is subordinate to the debt my entity owes to me.
I then 'spend that money' on developing the game.
What I actually do is spend it on a huge salary for me, and company expenses and generally embezzel. I spend almost nothing on the game. When the company fails the investors don't get their money back because it's all subordinate to my first position debt through my other legal entity. In this way, I keep their money while the game is being developed and I also keep receipts from the sale through my superior debt instrument when I liquidate.
I spend as little as I can on development, but spend enough on rendering gameplay footage for my investors that they believe a game is coming. That keeps them on the hook for years while I spend their money on myself, prior to winding it up.
The venture is an abject failure but highly successful for me.
That's an asset flip scam. It's not a new playbook either. It's exactly this kind of arrangement that good tech investors spend a lot of time and money on due diligence to avoid accidently investing in.
It's very common in bad software companies from parts of the world like Russia, but you'll find it in the USA too.
The problem is that platforms like Steam enable every player to be an 'investor' by buying the game. Most lack the ability to perform due diligence on the company to the same degree that they'll buy into the hype vs. Common sense.
This new narrative that there is no way the studio made money is bullshit. They could very very easily have made a lot of money, and likely did.