RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/TheDigitalCircus • … • u/FoxyDepression

A Genuine Explanation of Jax Being Trans In Show

I see a lot of people still expressing confusion about how Jax's transgender identity is represented in the show or concluding that it wasn’t represented at all besides a couple scenes. I think part of the problem is that Jax’s character arc portrays the experiences of trans people in a more overarching way than can be represented in individual scenes. I have seen some posts similar to this but I have not been personally satisfied with their explanations, so I wanted to try my hand at it. I am a notoriously long-winded person and I wanted my explanation to be more thorough than others, but I did still try to reign myself in and keep things digestible for everyone. Also note that I have dyslexia so there will be spelling grammar mistakes. I will fix them if they are pointed out to me. I'm going to start by listing moments in the show I think are relevant to the discussion and then I'm going to talk about some overall themes and how they relate to being trans

# Relevant Scenes Roughly in Order of Depiction:

* In episode 1, after Kaufmo abstracts, Jax runs off and meets up with Kinger and Gangle. Jax lies about Kaufmo's condition and carries on pretending everything is fine. This is the start of a pattern of Jax denying an inconvenient truth and substituting it with a more comfortable lie. * In Episode 3, Jax refuses to share what happens when he holds his breath. This is the start of another trend of Jax withholding even basic information about himself and redirecting attention away from himself with humor or mockery of others * In episode 3 Caine calls the cast his "milkmaids" and Jax responds by telling him not to call him that. This is the only time Caine's strange terms of endearment use gendered language and the only time Jax reacts to them. Jax does not react when being called "Jaxy Boy" in episode 3 or "Bunny Boy" in episode 6 * On a similar note, multiple times Jax refers to other female characters with gendered language such as "ladies" twice in episode 1 as well as "the gals and I" and “damsels” both in episode 7. I did not notice any other character referring to others via their gender in this way * In episode 5, during Gangle's anime-inspired adventure, Jax emphasises how “embarrassing” Gangle’s interests are. Jax also describes himself crying during his conversation with Ribbit in episode 9 as "embarrassing." * During the nighttime picnic, Ragatha criticizes Jax's behavior towards Gangle. Despite observations to the contrary, Jax claims that Gangle actually enjoys his bullying. When Pomni questions his previous claims to not care what others think, Jax becomes flustered and stutters out an unconvincing denial that he does * After Ragatha leaves, Jax criticizes her for "trying way too hard" and "pretending everything's always fine." He then accuses telling others they're "loved and appreciated" as a means to take advantage of them. Jax frequently shows disdain towards expressions of empathy, particularly those from Ragatha as well as suspicion towards invitations for emotional intimacy. * Next, Jax states that his character body is what "peak male performance” looks like and that his "ears and tail are kind of the pinnacle of masculinity" before being informed that his tail has been missing for a long period of time * During the bar scene Jax makes multiple comments mocking Zooble's career history for fitting into stereotypes about genderqueer people. He also accuses Zooble of "hiding something," which they, in turn, accuses him of as well * When it is Jax's turn to share background information about himself, he once again deflects with humor and never volunteers any details about himself * When Jax is again confronted about his bullying towards Gangle, he states that the other characters are "\[taking\] this place way too seriously,” mirroring the belief system he will share next episode. This is, of course, immediately undermined when he is confronted with something he has a phobia of, expresses anger at Zooble for mocking him, and reacts in fear. This is also another example of Jax hiding even basic information about himself by denying his fear of corn * During the softball game, Jax expresses intense contempt for evil Jax, which he reiterates every time Evil Jax acts shy or polite.  As soon as he has the opportunity, Jax attacks evil Jax by biting him like a rapid dog. Evil Jax’s demeanor bears a notable resemblance to both Gangle and Piano Jax from episode 9. * The Maid Dress. When Jax is put into the maid dress against his will, he reacts stronger than any other situation we have seen him in. It is the only instance of him physically attacking someone for non-comedic purposes. He specifically states that he does not want to go up to bat because he "looks like this" and expresses anger when Evil Jax attempts to compliment his appearance. He reacts even more when Zooble suggests he might be "into" the dress and aggressively questions what they mean by that. Zooble even states they "have never seen \[Jax\] this upset about something." Jax does not react to any of the other numerous outfits he is put in throughout the series * When Jax returns to the dug out, Pomni inquires about his condition and he answers sarcastically before turning attention to mocking Gangle.  * In episode 6, when Pomni asks to be partners with Jax, Jax questions if she is "sure \[she\] can handle \[him\] in all my glory" while gesturing to his body, not dissimilar to his boasting at the picnic. * Later when they are in the bedroom hallway, Jax expresses his view that the cast are no longer real people but are "just cartoon characters." He believes that things that used to matter in their previous life, no longer matter in the circus such as the wellbeing of others or authenticity to their previous personhood. Jax encourages Pomni to abandon her previous view of herself and adopt a new cartoonish persona to act out her impulses. Jax will later use this framing during their fight after the game to invalidate and dismiss her feelings by saying, "Dude, you're a cartoon clown. How am I supposed to take you seriously?" * After killing Ragatha and while looking for Kinger, Pomni asks Jax about his fear of corn and provides evidence of his fear to prevent him from denying it. Jax talks briefly about his trypophobia until Pomni comments that she's "learning a lot about him today." Jax tenses up and redirecting the conversation to the game * At the end of the gun game, Jax begins to emotionally distance himself from Pomni. When she tries to clarify their relationships, Jax not only rejects her friendship but denies that events took place as they did and tells her that she "must be misremembering." * When Pomni accuses Jax of contributing to people's abstractions, Jax breaks from his dismissive demeanor to yell at her until he catches himself and reverts back to being emotionally distant. This repeats later when he gets upset at Pomni for attacking him, leading to another moment of him catching himself and trying to save face.  * During Jax and Pomni's fight after the gun game, Jax asserts that people are “not pleasant” to be around before they abstract, which does not match with the memory of these events we see in Jax’s mind later on. * Jax denies that he is a "misunderstood little chicken fetus in an egg that needs to be cracked open." "Egg" is a term in the trans community for a trans person who has not realized or accepted that they are trans. Their egg is "cracked" when they acknowledge themselves as trans. Not only would Goose be familiar with this term and willing to mock her self-insert with it, but I also think this statement sticks out as a strange phrase for Jax to use without this context * At the end of their fight, Jax states "there's nothing more to me, so please just stop looking" with a sad expression as if he is begging Pomni not to continue seeking out his authentic self. * During the Favorite Character Awards, Jax goes to the backroom and has an anxiety attack, similar to the ones he will have in episodes 7, 8, and 9. All 4 anxiety attacks come after confronting a reality he is denying. In this case, he slipped up during his fight with Pomni and let some of his real feelings be seen, feelings he aggressive denies having * Jax makes multiple comments about his appearance, beginning in the bathroom scene when he looks into the mirror and states that he “looks stupid.” Jax repeats this phrase in episode 9 when first seeing himself in the mirror after arriving in the circus. Later in episode 9, he once again sees himself in the mirror after running from Kaufmo's abstraction and remarks "You're not looking too good. You gonna cry? Looking like this?" * In episode 7, while at the beach, Jax snidely asks Zooble, "aren't you supposed to be miserable about your ability to choose your own body?" The wording of this question frames "ability to choose your own body" as a positive and Jax's tone reads almost like jealousy. When Zooble goes on to talk about how "the ability to change is fine, not needing to commit to one thing all the time," Jax responds with an aloof "how about that." Zooble seems to judge this as a concerning answer and encourages him to open up to others. Jax rejects this suggestion by asserting that he "doesn't have any problems" * Before Jax begins abstracting in his room, he seems a ghostly version of his own hands. Touching the vague alternate version of himself initiates the abstraction sequence * When Jax is awoken from his abstraction, his eyes are light blue and pink with similar shades to the trans flag. While not compelling evidence on its own, it is the exact type of joke that I think Goose and crew would make at Jax's expense. * Jax's room is pink with rainbows and cutesy patterns reminiscent of a little girl's room, not even an adult woman’s room * When confronted with Able and the possibility of leaving the circus, Jax immediately rejects the idea and suspects that it is a trick. * Later, when Zooble asks him if he wants to leave the circus, Jax appears nervous and stutters out an unconfident answer * As the cast approaches the admin console, Jax becomes increasingly nervous until he begins having an anxiety attack and impulsively pushes the button to stay in the circus. The uncomfortable reality he is denying in this scene is whatever personal issues and difficult emotions he would have to face if he left the circus * When Caine reveals that all of episode 7 was an adventure, Jax reacts with anger and yells at Caine for lying. This sentiment is repeated in episode 8 when he criticizes Caine for "lying to \[them\] constantly." This is a very hypocritical thing for Jax to be upset about given his very well established pattern of dishonesty. Similar to Evil Jax and Gangle, this may be because Caine is reflecting an aspect of himself that he dislikes * In episode 8, when Kinger starts providing backstory on Caine, Jax becomes very uncomfortable and leaves the room to have an anxiety attack. The uncomfortable reality in this scene is the realization that the circus is not a self-contained, dream-like world outside of reality and exists within the real world * Jax's torture sequences involves him being surrounded by shadows of Ribbit, Kaufmo, and Pomni laughing at him before forcibly removing his skin. This reflects Jax's fear of losing his outer facade and having his vulnerable inner self exposed and then rejected or mocked by people he cares about. Notably, his vulnerability is symbolized by discomfort with his body, which he covers up with embarrassment * In episode 9, when Kinger reveals that the cast are brain scans, Jax teases Zooble and Ragatha with aspects of their real lives they're missing out on before reflecting on his own life and uttering "Guess I'm still..." and trailing off. It’s possible Jax is imagining that his real life counterpart has not yet transitioned and is still living as a man * 3 of the 4 abstractions we've seen were precipitated by the character in question approaching someone else and making one last attempt to connect with them before giving up and self-isolating. Goose has stated that abstraction is meant to be reminiscent of suicide, which is often proceeded by similar behavior. It's also worth saying that the trans community has an extremely elevated risk of suicide * Within Jax's mind, the second door Pomni opens depicts a fantasy of Jax after Zooble's death in which he wears a maid's dress to the funeral and remarks that he is wearing it to "\[honor\] Zooble spirit" by doing “something all gender-freaky." * The third Pomni examine is barracked with metal bars and chained shut. The picture of Jax scene on the other doors in his mind is scratched out. Note that this door is different from the one Pomni unlocks with a key later on that contains the "real" Jax.  * We see this door again later in the bar-like room. When there is a knock at the door, all the other Jaxs immediately drop what they’re doing to tell whichever Jax is on the other side to be quiet. They then return to their card game and continue ignoring the door. * We never see what is behind this door, which is in contrast to other deeply kept secrets of Jax’s such as possibly killing his mother and his relationship with Ribbit. Regardless of what is behind the door, this showcases that there are still parts of Jax's mind that are locked up and unacknowledged.  * When Pomni enters the 5th door containing the bar-like room full of Jax, the Jax in the maid dress remarks that there is a "strict 'no girls allowed' policy." * Maid Dress Jax also states that he is wearing the dress "ironically" to "show truly just how little \[he\] cares” before calling another Jax a “f\*ggot.” This is in contrast with the Jax next to them who does care enough to express disapproval of the dress. After this exchange, another Jax declares that he can play the piano to which Maid Dress responds "if you have to say you can play the piano, it makes it seem like you can't actually play. This is ironic, because the paraphrased sentiment "the more you insist upon something, the less believable it becomes" is said by the character most insistent he isn't wearing the dress because he enjoys it and so eager to hurl homophobic insults at others. In short, the lady doth protest too much * When Pomni attempts to push back against Jax's fantasies by saying that they "aren't reality," all of the Jaxs express a negative view of reality. * Maid Jax specifically remarks that "reality's gay" This statement could be seen as a literal description of Jax’s reality. (Note that people with anti-LGBT attitudes such as Maid Dress Jax do not care enough to distinguish between different identities such as sexual orientation vs gender identity and will use them interchangeably. It's all just "gay shit" to them) * When describing his relationship with his mom, Jax specifically recalls that she frequently insulted his masculinity and compared him to his father. It is implied this is not the only kind of insult Jax's mom threw at him, but the fact that he brings it up first and focuses on it the most may suggest that it is the type of insult that most affected him and thus he remembers most prominently.  * Jax states he told his mother something "deep and personal that \[he\] thought would get \[him\] off her back." Since insults to Jax's masculinity seemed to be the most significant, either because they were the most common or the most painful, this suggests that this confession was related to his gender in some way. * After Jax pushes his mother away, he runs away from the home without ever confirming if she is alive or dead, once again avoiding an uncomfortable reality. Jax also ends up homeless after this event, which is also extremely prevalent among trans youth and young adults due to lack of family support * Ribbit states that his "secret is safe with \[her.\]". This could refer to Jax possibly killing his mother or to the confession he made to his mother prior to their fight. * After Jax opens up, Ribbit takes the bow she wears and places it on Jax's head. This is an uncommon way to comfort someone describing family trauma in comparison to holding his hand or putting a hand on his shoulder. A bow is also not typically seen as a very sentimental item in comparison to something like a necklace or locket. Jax reacts to the bow with a large blush, wide eyes, and then a shy smile. When Kaufo interrupts the moment, his first instinct is to not only remove the bow, but throw it away from him so he is not seen with it even near him * When Ribbit approaches Jax after their moment together, Jax denies that the interaction happened the way it did and that they ever had a friendship to begin with. He goes so far to suggest the interaction was inauthentic or fabricated in some way in addition to accusing her of manipulating him. He is very adamant to assert multiple times that "there is nothing there."  * The song “Isn't She Lovely” is about the birth of Stevie Wonder’s daughter and the section used includes the lyrics "only one minute old" and "making one as lovely as she." The images included in this montage are taken from scenes featuring Jax. Some scenes included other characters, but no one character is consistently included in group scenes. Some scenes only included Jax on his own. It is safe to conclude that Jax is the subject of this montage and thus that Jax is the “She” that is “Lovely” and “less than one minute old.” * At the very end of the series, when Caine is showing the lives of their human counterparts, Leeroy is intentionally covering his face in every picture. This could be another expression of his discomfort or insecurity in his appearance * It is also stated that Leeroy is a frequent visitor of Riley’s bar, a “hip alternative destination where they can feel like themselves, free of judgement.” It's safe to assume that Riley’s bar is at least explicitly queer-friendly if not an openly queer bar. The fact that Leeroy’s other friends also visit regularly suggests that he may have surrounded himself with other queer people, on purpose or unconsciously * Leeroy’s presentation is similar to how many trans women present when they are first testing the waters or beginning transition. “Boymode” is a term in the trans community to describe the way a trans woman presents when she is still in the closet or not yet able to pass as a woman. It typically includes wearing baggy, gender neutral clothing to disguise parts of their body that they are uncomfortable with while avoiding bringing attention to themselves. It may also include some feminine features, but only those inconspicuous enough to have plausible deniability such as longer hair that is still within the bounds of a possible male hair cut or painted nails with neutral colors like black. Leeroy’s presentation at the bus stop is a spot-on example of what a closeted trans woman often looks like. * While Leeroy may still be identifying as a man in public and on his social media, many trans people begin their transition in private and wait until they are further along in the process before transitioning publicly. Some may change their name and pronouns only among friends. Some may be taking HRT secretly and disguise their body until their desired primary/secondary sex characteristics are more developed, aiding in their ability to pass.

Exclusions from this list: Instances of Jax antagonizing Ragatha and Gangle as well as instances of Jax instigating or participating in violence towards others, because they were far too many to list so I hope we can just all agree these are well defined parts of his character. Scenes depicting Jax’s feelings towards his mother and Ribbit exclusively without any relevance to his gender. Jax’s history of familial abuse and interpersonal conflict are equally important facets of his character that help inform his actions, but they are not the subject of this post.

# Themes:

**Insecurity and Overcompensation** It’s clear to see that Jax is deeply insecure. He claims that the members of the circus are “just cartoon characters” who take things “way too seriously” to disregard their feelings, but transparently shows his emotions and cannot handle being the butt of the joke. Jax has the strongest reactions when he is perceived as sensitive, vulnerable, unmasculine, or caring for others. He is terrified of being embarrassed, hides any potentially unflattering details about himself, and views any information about him as a potential weakness for someone to exploit. As a defensive mechanism, Jax overcompensates to distract from the parts of him he doesn’t want people to notice. He portrays himself as aloof, invulnerable, hyper masculine, and detached from others. Jax won’t even let others enjoy something as mainstream as anime without ridicule and an emphasis on his dislike of it, just to make sure everyone knows that he’s too cool to be into it. Multiple characters even point out Jax’s tendency to deflect attention away from himself via humor or bullying. Jax also puts a lot of focus on the way he physically looks and a lot of conversation is pointed towards the idea that he is hiding something specific about himself, with Zooble seeming to have particular insight into this.

I don’t think anyone will be surprised to hear that many trans people struggle with negative self-image. Gender dysphoria can make people very sensitive to the way they are perceived by others, physically and emotionally. It can be very painful to have the undesirable parts of themselves acknowledged and cause strong emotional reactions such as lashing out at others.. While it can be uncomfortable to acknowledge, and is clearly not representative of a majority of the group, some trans people attempt to cover up their feelings by adopting a toxic personality that drives others away, leaving them isolated, bitter, and confused. This can be particularly difficult for trans women who, like cis men and other amab (assigned male at birth) people, were raised to suppress their emotions and never given the tools to understand their emotional needs. Hurt people hurt people and all that

**Femininity and Gender** The topic of gender comes up around Jax very frequently and he seems to have a specific pre-occupation with it, even though it is largely unmentioned by any other character. Even Zooble discusses their issues with body-image without specifically referencing sex characteristics. Several of the traits described in the previous section fall into line with the concept of toxic masculinity. Not only does Jax have a fragile ego and views emotions as weakness, but he actively bullies others and has an exaggerated taste for aggression and violence. Additionally, Jax shows near-constant disdain for things associated with femininity, such as empathy, communication, interpersonal cooperation, and emotional openness. Jax’s bullying is almost exclusively directed at women, most often Gangle and Ragatha, with Pomni and Zooble only catching occasional strays. Some may attribute this to the majority female cast. However, I think the scale of difference between his treatment of these characters vs the only other male character is very stark. Kinger is debatably the most vulnerable and easily targeted member of the circus yet I only counted 2 mild insults Jax ever directs at him. Jax is also extremely uncomfortable interacting with feminine clothing such as the maid’s dress and Ribbit’s bow, physically throwing them away from him when he gets the chance. The irony is that the narrative consistently undermines Jax’s masculinity and brings attention to his interest in femininity. His attempts at boasting about his masculinity often fall flat and everything from his room to the representations of his inner-mind are dressed in feminine clothing. Jax’s relationship to gender, in combination with his tendency to overcompensate for insecurities suggests that Jax’s overly masculine persona is meant to cover up a strong connection/interest in femininity.

This again parallels the experiences of many trans people. Prior to coming out, it is very common for trans people to lean into their assigned gender at birth. Sometimes this is due to overcompensation. Sometimes this is because they misattribute their unhappiness to an inability to properly fulfill their gender role and think being their gender the “right” way will solve their problems. Some go so far as to fall into extremist subcultures such as the manosphere or alt-right pipeline. For some, it is only after they explore their assigned gender at birth thoroughly that they come to the realization that there is no version of that gender that satisfies them and their only option to find peace is to become a different gender entirely. Much like a horribly homophobic bully turning out to be gay themself, some of the most misogynistic, toxically masculine men or tradfem women turn out to be trans. It is not a dignified or consequence-free path to take through life, but it is a very real and very human one.

**Avoidance of Reality** We have seen on many occasions that Jax will not only avoid emotionally difficult situations, but will outright deny that they exist and substitute them with a more convenient narrative. He avoids feeling guilty for Ribbit and Kaufmo’s abstraction by telling Pomni that they were the ones acting out, not him. He avoids facing the cruelty of his actions against Gangle by asserting that she isn’t affected by it. He avoids his own feelings towards the circus by suggesting that being a “cartoon character” prevents him from having any. Jax is so scared of facing unpleasant realities that he runs away before even confirming that his mother is dead and potentially dooms everyone to stay in the circus forever by pressing the red button. Jax is aware of his upcoming abstraction at least as far back as episode 7 but never confides in anyone nor does seemingly anything to avoid it. It does not matter how obvious, important, or dangerous the truth is, Jax will sacrifice literally anything to avoid it, even himself. As we see by the remaining locked door in his mind after he abstracts, he took his secrets to the grave

Admitting that you’re transgender can be one of the most terrifying things a person ever has to do. Doing so not only permanently alters your understanding of yourself but often requires significant, difficult changes to your life and planned future. For many trans people, there isn’t one single moment that makes them realize that they are trans. It sneaks up on them slowly over a long course of time, beginning as a small thought and growing into a unnamed monster that looms over every moment of their lives. The longer it goes on, the larger the shadow in their mind grows and the harder it is to confront. As seen by the severe mortality rate for trans people who are unable to access gender-affirming healthcare, the decision to transition often comes down to life or death. adding even more pressure and making it even scarier to consider. In the end, it is often only until they have exhausted all other options and can no longer repress what they already know, that they are finally forced to look at the options in front of them. They can either show tremendous courage and face their truth or they can live in denial until it kills them. It takes some people until their 30s, 40s, 50s, even 60s to accept their identity. And tragically, there are many who are never able to do so and they too take that secret to their grave.

The unbearable reality that Jax is so desperately avoiding, the terrifying inner thought that gives him anxiety attacks just to consider, the secret he dedicated much of his personality to distracting himself and others from, is that he feels more like a woman than a man. And it is his adamant refusal to confront this fact about himself, in addition to his self-imposed social isolation and history of trauma, that causes him to abstract.

# Common Questions:

**A lot of the experiences you describe are relatable to other people too. Why can it only mean that Jax is trans?** You are absolutely correct. I’ve seen a lot of people talk about how they related to Jax as a non-stereotypical man, a non-trans queer person, a victim of abuse, someone struggling with insecurity, and more. Almost none of the experiences I described are exclusive to trans people and most of the people in the world who experience those feelings aren’t trans, but they are also trans experiences. When Goose set out to write a story about a trans character, it only makes sense to include issues like insecurity, family conflict, body-image, and so on. Many of which come from Goose’s own life. Trans people have as much right to these experiences as anyone else and in this specific case, they were building towards a trans story. I imagine that if Jax’s story had leaned more into his history of trauma or non-gender insecurities, there would not be as many people accusing it of monopolizing specific experiences. I think we would all understand that it is showing only one character’s relationship to these things without trying to exclude anyone else and the same is true here. We are not in opposition to each other. We are affected by many of the same problems and we are all in solidarity against restrictive gender roles.

**Well why can’t it be left ambiguous so people can have their own interpretations?** Queer stories are often responded to in very different ways than non-queer stories. There is a historical trend of the queer elements of a story being censored, erased, or downplayed. This has contributed to the limited number of queer stories allowed to be told with trans people in particular being left with an absolute dearth of options. As such, it is important for there to be openly queer stories and for that queerness to be made as explicit and undeniable as possible to push back against any potential naysaying. The bottom line is that Goose wanted to tell a trans story, as she is allowed to do, and she is under no obligation to make that story ambiguous or catered to non-trans people if she doesn’t want to.

The good news is that this most certainly does not stop alternate interpretations. While confirming that Jax is trans is important for representation purposes and I do think it is important for any fan of the story to understand that his story was meant to be trans, authorial intent has never prevented anyone from inserting their own ideas and experiences into a narrative, nor do I think Goose would be against such interpretations. You are more than welcome to twist the elements of Jax’s story or examine them from different angles in whatever way you wish. Say that you view him as an alpha male if you want. I would simply ask that you be careful not to undermine the wider significance of Jax as trans representation and be respectful towards trans topics generally.

**A huge portion of the audience didn’t recognize Jax was trans at all. Shouldn’t Goose have made that more clear to a general audience?** There’s a phenomenon that a lot of lesbian couples, including myself, experience (and maybe other queer couples, I’m more familiar with the wlw side of things) in which they are in public, participating in typical romantic activities, yet people around them will not understand that they are in a romantic relationship. The couple can be holding hands, cuddling up together, feeding each other while looking lovingly into the other’s eyes, and people will assume that they are close friends or even siblings. It isn’t until things cross over into exclusively romantic forms of affection that they are shocked to realize they have seen one of those rare homosexuals in the wild. In a similar vein, there is a joke within the LGBT community that you can have a character aggressively making out with another character of the same gender, and the audience will still say “they’re just very platonically affectionate” or have a character look directly and state their gender identity and the audience will still say “they’re just in touch with their feminine/masculine side.”

My point is that the general population simply does not think about queer people very much and doesn’t know much about them. Of all the possible theories people were coming up with for Jax’s backstory, being trans was as viable of a possibility as anything else. The evidence I listed at the start was always there and lots of people clocked Jax as trans as far back as episode 5 with even more recognizing it after the finale. But most people didn’t even consider as a possibility, because they probably just didn’t think of it. As a counter example, it was very common for people to theorize that Jax might have been in a car accident of some kind, based almost exclusively off of an out-of-context flashback of a car being driven. People were more willing to believe that Jax was in a hit and run from only one car-related scene than they were to believe that his obvious insecurity might be related to gender dysphoria.

I’ve seen a lot of people describe terms like “egg” and “boymode” as “niche” terms you’d only understand if you’re deep into the trans community. It’s worth clarifying that these are extremely common words. If you spend more than 5 minutes in a queer space or have trans friends, you’ll come across them. I still wouldn’t expect the average person to have heard them, but that’s not because they’re really underground, deep-cut references. It’s because most people are so unfamiliar with the trans community that they don’t recognize even the most basic, surface-level products of its culture. I saw a lot of people asking questions like “if Jax is trans, why didn’t he act more girly?” and “why didn’t he like the maid dress?” And I respect their willingness to ask questions. I am more than happy to answer them, but if that is the level of awareness we are starting from, it’s no wonder the reveal came as a surprise to most.

The sad truth is that there isn’t really a way to tell a trans story that a general audience will understand. There are plenty of trans stories far more obvious and explicit than this than get just as little recognition. And Goose was never under any obligation to spoon-feed the information to anyone. That said, if you’re confused or unclear on any of the topics people are discussing around Jax’s identity, I genuinely encourage you to take this opportunity to expose yourself to a group of people you may not have interacted with much before. Here are [two](https://transequality.org/trans-101) [places ](https://www.apa.org/topics/lgbtq/transgender-people-gender-identity-gender-expression)to start. Perhaps you will even be able to start noticing us in the places you didn’t see us before but where we have always been

**If Jax is meant to be trans, why is he such an asshole and why is he killed?** There is a diversity of opinion within the LGBT community on how queer characters should be depicted in media. Some people are of the opinion that any queer character will automatically be seen by the viewing audience as a representation of the community and thus, queer characters should work as positive exposure, pushing back against negative stereotypes and portraying an optimistic view of queerness. Others find these restrictions to be stifling. Some think that the influence of any one queer story is limited and that a queer artist should not be pressured to cater to a non-queer audience. They may think it is more important to provide queer people with realistic depictions of their experiences and prefer queer characters who are allowed to be flawed and human. Some trans people are, in fact, assholes and plenty of us die. The correct answer is that there should be more queer characters in general so that no one individual character has to carry the burden of everyone’s conflicting expectations. Luckily, the Amazing Digital Circus has, not one, but two non-cis characters of very different kinds. If you prefer a neutral to positive portrayal of a queer character who has a healthy view of their identity and is allowed a happy ending, may I please direct your attention to my good friend Zooble, who was likely included in the cast partially to push back against this exact criticism. If neither Jax or Zooble are to your taste, or you would like even more stories like theirs, please feel free to seek other additional queer stories and expose yourself to a diversity of experiences. For something middle of the road, I recommend Nimona.

**Some people were really shitty about this whole thing and I didn’t appreciate it** I feel like I have presented a very reasonable view into some LGBT issues that many people have been and continue to be very negatively affected by. Trans people are particularly vulnerable even within the community and there are on-going large-scale political attacks against them in several countries. This is a very significant topic that a lot of people, rightly, have very strong feelings about. That is not an excuse for bad behavior. No one deserves to be insulted, harassed, or hurt over fictional character discourse. As mentioned, there are far bigger problems to direct our energy towards and the LGBT community should be held to the same standards of respect that others are as well. I am sorry that you were treated poorly. You did not deserve that. That being said, I would like to kindly ask that you extend some grace to anyone who has directed their pain at you.  Although most people probably didn’t have an ill-will towards any trans person, a lot of the commentary around Jax has mirrors real world transphobia that motivates harm against us. Sometimes sentiments like “well I didn’t notice anything trans about him” are the same words someone’s parents may have thrown at them while accusing them of being brainwashed by social media. Sometimes questions like “why can’t he just be a feminine man?” are the same questions someone’s doctor directed towards them while denying them access to gender-affirming care. Sometimes criticisms like “shouldn’t he have been more obviously trans?” are spit by romantic partners who think they got tr\*pped. Hurt people hurt people and this is a very hurt community. I would also like to bring attention to the fact that only a portion of people are active internet users. Only a minority spend time on Reddit specifically and only a minority of Reddit users are interested in our youtube cartoon. Statistics show that while about half of people actively participate in online discussion with 80% of comments being left 20% of users. And that's not including age demographics. Any disrespectful behavior you witnessed is not representative of a majority of either the trans community nor the world at large. The loudest, meanest voices are not the most important. Most people have moderate, nuanced views that they may or may not choose to voice online. Please try to keep your impression of any online interaction within this perspective.

# Ongoing Discussion

In addition to all the usual commentary, I would like to open this up as a forum for anyone to ask any LGBT-related question they may usually be uncomfortable asking. I cannot speak on behalf of all trans people, nor will I likely be able to answer every question, so I hope others will chime in to share their experiences as well. Let’s make this a moment of mutual understanding so that Jax's story can spread wider awareness of trans experiences and maybe someone else like Jax will be able to find a happier ending for themselves.

— 0