RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/TheLastOfUs2 • … • u/wub1234

A Published Novelist Explains why TLOU2 is Poorly Written

I've been wanting to write this for a long time, and finally got round to it last night. So, without further ado, this is going to be a long post...

**The events that initiate the story seem completely implausible**

It's hard to believe that a group fighting what is an ongoing and bloody conflict would suddenly allow several of its key members to travel halfway across the country, for something that doesn't benefit the WLF in the slightest, on what could clearly be a wild goose chase. This is a central plot vehicle that, in common with so much else in the game, seems completely contrived.

**How did they find Joel in a world without any external communication or circulation of information?**

We managed to track Joel down to this location in Jackson. Admittedly, he could be absolutely anywhere in the United States, or even dead, and we have zero feasible methods of communication or research, but, hey, we managed to find him anyway.

**Characters are not internally conflicted enough**

The most important thing with any narrative is to ensure that the audience buys into the story. As soon as the reader, or player in this case, suspends their disbelief, you've lost them for good.

It is therefore critical to craft characters that behave in typical human fashion. And one of the prevailing characteristics of virtually all people is that we are constantly torn with internal conflicts. We doubt ourselves, and we question the decisions that we make.

In my first published novel, the central character decides to leave his family and abandon his homeland. Throughout the narrative, it was therefore essential for me to demonstrate that while his resolution to set out on this journey was sincere, there were always nagging doubts, and even regrets, at the back of his mind. This is essential to keep the reader in the story, as otherwise anyone reading the book is liable to think: “why doesn't this character care about his family? This doesn't ring true”.

Not ringing true is precisely how I would describe the behaviour of every character in TLOU2. Ellie, for example, puts herself through absolute hell, but never for one second loses her conviction (until, of course, she can actually kill Abby, when she, completely implausibly, experiences doubts for the first time). We therefore don't really believe in Ellie; she has simply become another vehicle for the game to stand on its proverbial soapbox.

Abby is ready to reject everything she knows far too easily. Owen suddenly decides that the Fireflies are the greatest thing since sliced bread, and is determined to abandon his pregnant partner. And there are other examples. Speaking of which...

**Ellie's survivors guilt is way too strong**

I can believe that Ellie *could* have survivor's guilt, but surely she would feel at least somewhat grateful for, you know, not being dead! This is a rather fundamental attribute of human beings, and indeed all sentient creatures; favouring this state of not being dead, over, you know, being dead! Survival is a central tenet of the first game; in the second game, the characters can barely wait to put themselves in life-threatening situations!

On a side note, Joel also intrinsically understands that Ellie would want to sacrifice her own life for the cause of saving humanity, even though she has never explicitly expressed this.

**Characters always align with deeply held values and some 'cause' that seemingly rages inside them, rather than more mundane and typical human considerations**

I have touched on this already, but virtually every character in TLOU2 is motivated by some deep-rooted cause or value, and this then obviates any other feeling or instinct that they would usually possess. Again, this is not the way that human beings behave. We get tired, scared, hungry, horny, depressed, lonely, homesick, etc. We have a wide range of emotions and motivations. We don't simply have one central stimulus that completely overrides everything else.

We can contrast this with the first game, in which Joel, Tess, and later Bill, are focused purely on survival. Other minor characters, such as Robert, are motivated by greed and similarly selfish motivations. Eileen wants Ellie kept safe, Ellie is full of childlike wonder, Tommy cares about his compound and family, Joel later feels very protective towards Ellie, and so on.

In the first game, the motivations of the characters feel authentic, in the second game everything feels concocted and poorly founded.

**There is no effort to explore and build upon the most interesting location**

I felt really cheated that we left Jackson so quickly, without exploring any of the aspects that are touched upon, particularly as it turns out to be by far the most interesting location in the game. Again, this was an issue that I faced in my first published novel, thus I had to ensure that every location visited was more colourful and compelling than the protagonist's homeland, so that the reader wants to spend time there. There was no such consideration made in TLOU2; Jackson is cast aside as untapped potential.

In fact, the original idea that the writers had – for Abby to somehow infiltrate Jackson, appear to be a sympathetic character, and then murder Joel – would have been far more interesting. Wouldn't you have loved to go out on reconnaissance missions searching for infected? Wouldn't it have been interesting to be immersed in Jackson, to get to know more residents, to see what daily life was like there? No, the writers decided that it would be more enjoyable to endure a laborious search for medical supplies, and to then kill the related character off almost immediately.

**Characters fail to give simple explanations, so that contrived conflict can be created**

The best example of this is that Joel could have said the following to Ellie: “look, Ellie. When we arrived at the Fireflies, you were unconscious. They took you away from me, and held me at gunpoint. They were very aggressive, and I got a bad vibe from them. They then told me that they would kill you. I couldn't allow this, particularly as there is no guarantee that killing you would really have helped the human race going forward. They also wanted to do this without seeking your consent”. This is a common flaw, present in many on-screen narratives; characters don't say things that you would really expect them to say, so that the narrative can be pushed in a certain direction. But just because it's common, doesn't make it any better here.

**Ellie / Dina / Jesse triangle is really strange, but no-one treats it as if it's strange**

Dina is pregnant with Jesse's child.

Dina then dumps Jesse for Ellie.

Jesse doesn't seem remotely bothered about this.

No-one admonishes Dina for breaking up a relationship which has led to her pregnancy, before the child is born, simply because, according to her, it wasn't going anywhere.

But she can't even have been pregnant for that long, as she wasn't visibly pregnant enough for Jesse to notice. So they were close enough to have sex pretty recently, intercourse that led to procreation, but now their relationship is completely over.

Ellie isn't bothered by this at all, and doesn't factor this into their potential relationship; she's perfectly happy to get together with someone who has just dumped the father of her child for virtually no reason, and the father happens to be one of her best friends.

Jesse is very close friends with Ellie, but doesn't care that she is getting together with his ex, and it doesn't impact on their friendship in the slightest.

He then decides to travel halfway across the country on what is basically a suicide mission, and...

Need I go on?

**No explanation given for Abby / Owen break-up**

Firstly, this makes little sense, particularly from a male perspective, as Owen then gets together with Mel, who is significantly less attractive than Abby. So we would need some reason why they split up, but this is never provided.

Secondly, giving no explanation for why they broke up then renders the whole section where they have sex, and reflect on Lev and Yara mirroring their relationship, completely meaningless, as we have no backstory to compare with.

Owen then also becomes interested in Abby again at the worst possible moment, when Mel is pregnant with his child. He then decides that he wants to disappear in search of the Fireflies, which seems a trifle selfish, given that he will be abandoning his own unborn child (see 'Characters always align with deeply held values and some 'cause'...).

**Major characters die without leaving any indelible impression, or even comment**

You cannot kill off central characters, never mention this or them again, and show zero signs of any impact on character development. I can think of few worse writing sins.

**No-one is ever concerned about dying**

I can accept that these characters live in a more hazardous world than you or I, and therefore have become hardened to the prospect of death. But fear is still part of the human constitution. Everyone in this story is completely fearless, taking the most insane risks without ever considering the potential consequences, and being largely unperturbed after experiencing the most incredibly traumatic situations.

**Travelling from one location to another seems bereft of any danger**

Just want to touch on this briefly; everyone is able to scoot around all over the place in this post-apocalyptic world on lengthy journeys, without ever encountering any danger, or even disturbance. You might recall in the first game that this was a little bit trickier.

**No-one gives a shit about the infected**

Pretty self-explanatory, but the infected barely merit any consideration at all, largely considered to be a minor irritation akin to a housefly.

**Abby's conversion is rushed and unconvincing**

It is plausible that she would feel grateful towards people who saved her life, and also that she could feel conflicted about the ongoing war. But it is not believable that she would suddenly abandon everything that is familiar to her, particularly when she has been feeling vulnerable. This is yet another example of a character showing no outward signs of feeling conflicted about his or her choices, instead being guided by some, rather implausible, smouldering cause within them that then completely dictates all of their behaviour.

Furthermore, you could argue that Lev and Yara trust Abby far too easily, considering that she has been a central figure in what represents a lengthy annihilation of their people.

**The player is expected to evolve when we witness things, but the characters never do**

The game generally has quite a hectoring tone, and, clearly, as players we are required to change our perspective on events and / or characters at certain points in the story. For example, one character saves the life of another character, and the character whose life is saved then spares the life of someone who is trying to kill her.

— 0