Raye and Olivia Dean remind me how crazy mainstream American pop has become in its pursuit of perfect image
At first it was going to be a post on Raye and Olivia Dean as their respective hits were my very favourites in Todd's top-10 (ok, Sombr would make top-3, didn't care much for the rest of it). Now Adele is a thing of herself isolated from everyday culture and her roots (like MJ was increasingly since *Bad*, I guess), these two are becoming big stars of a new generation of British R&B. They obviously share a lot of similarities: both mixed, both BRITS alumni, both immaculately trained and versatile singers (to the point I'm afraid the last good superstar American singer to break out was, ehmm, Beyoncé?), both kind of obsessed with a role of men in their life. Also they both feel so unbearably natural both in their looks (both look very much like they did in their teens and have lovely unbotoxed expressions) and their songwriting. And the latter fells like real stories about themselves, not made ambivalently wide in pursuit of building para-social connection to fans (to be fair, they're not big enough yet to have one).
It contrasts sharply with American celebrity culture where 1) as I mentioned above, none of big female pop stars since Beyoncé have been particularly great singers; 2) everyone feels so much more insecure about their imperfections that they either build the whole image to feel perfect, cool and on the top of the world to their fans (fixing their looks too almost without exceptions), or make a protest against insecurities of their self-perception somewhat a central part of image (Billie Eilish, to some extent Chappell Roan, but I need to think more about her). Probably the only exclusion that's really big at the moment is SZA who, not being a rapper, feels very much like a part of hip-hop scene, so I don't wanna be covering it here − let's see where Doechii goes next, I guess. There are, obviously, other nice R&B and indie artists who fall off this paradigm, but they never broke (and many sure didn't want to) into pop mainstream
Then I thought that other biggest non-American English-speaking stars to break out this century: Robbie Williams, Amy Winehouse, Adele (really hope her weight loss was for health, not to conform into American culture), Ed Sheeran , Lorde, Charli XCX, the 1975 and Harry Styles − were also much more willing to naturally present themselves and make both their natural features and their personal struggles a part of songwriting and persona. Almost all of forementioned (and Raye too) were at some point of their lives or still are substance addicts (Ed being exception in both cases, but I just can' get over a guy looking like Ed becoming a celeb in the 1st place). I believe many Americans were too - but perhaps the crazy social pressure during upbringing makes it impossible to address. Both Lorde and Ariana Grande have problems with appearance self-perception and eating disorders, but the way they handle it, Lorde admitting and then seemingly getting over it while Ariana turning into anxious all-denying female MJ of our times.
Ok, there's also Dua Lipa, but she lacks personality so that I really care anyway
I want to ask Americans here: is social pressure on famous people really this high and can one break into the mainstream avoiding it? Could a song as brave and honest as 'Escapism' start a big career over the ocean? Could your celebs solve problems as openly as Charli XCX and Lorde did, not self-embarassing oneself like Taylor Swift? Because now, being from a non-English speaking country, I guess I really want to root for Fourth British invasion to happen. Sad, according to their charts, British market isn't now profound enough to really make it big
Edit: I've been rightfully corrected that, besides Beyoncé, Ariana Grande is a great singer, which she totally is. I guess it only highlights how only one great vocalists a decade breaks big in America now