RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/TrueFilm • … • u/redtail_faye

Valid Critical Takes on "You Can See Everything"

There's obviously (and rightfully) a lot of discussion about this movie, but it's almost universally praised as "genius" and "reality bending" and "revolutionary". There are very few critical takes, and most of those aren't taken seriously or are immediately dismissed.

But that puts people in an awkward position: agree with the praise, or be cast as someone who doesn't "get it". There doesn't seem to be any room for, "I understand and appreciate what the movie is trying to do but I question how well it actually does it".

It makes discussing the movie a little frustrating. Criticism is usually met with "you didn't *get it*" or "they did that on purpose!".

But high concept claims that the movie is *really* about "truth" and "reality" and "subjectivity" aren't actually counterarguments or defenses.

There are legitimate criticisms of how effectively it explores those ideas. Does the ambiguity necessarily reveal something meaningful, or does it simply manufacture uncertainty by intentionally withholding or manipulating context? And if "manufacturing uncertainty" is "the point", then what is the ambiguity actually revealing? Is it just that "sometimes it's hard to know what's true"?

Do the reenactments deepen our understanding or mostly just add a layer of contrived performance?

Does acknowledging its own manipulation automatically make that manipulation more defensible or credible?

Those questions aren’t evidence that someone missed "the point". They’re questions about whether the movie really earns the significance people are attributing to it.

I’m not saying people should enjoy it less. I'm not even saying I didn't enjoy it myself (because I did). I’d just like there to be room to question its effectiveness without having my understanding of it questioned instead.

— 0