RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/UKPersonalFinance • … • u/Ok_West_6958

PSA: No, Regular Savers do not pay less than advertised

This is something I've seen a number of people get wrong, and it's quite closely coupled with a more general misunderstanding of how interest works (both for savings and for loans, but this post will be focussed on savings).

​

This is a bit of a beast of a post, and the TL;DR is that if you are making new contributions to savings, say from your salary (rather than just having an existing lump sum of savings to play with), then putting it into whatever account has the highest AER is the best thing to do\* - and this includes regular savers even if their monthly deposit limit is small. If you want an essay for why this is the case, as well as a more general savings deep dive, then please read on! (\*assuming the withdrawal terms meet your needs).

Many many people will already know how savings interest works, so they can move on as well. For those who are left:

​

Let's take the following example:

[Nationwide Flex Regular Saver](https://www.nationwide.co.uk/savings/flex-regular-saver/) advertises an 8% interest rate (AER specifically but we'll talk more about that later) for deposits of up to £200 a month. This piques your interest, so you flick through the info on their website and see the estimated balance after 12 months: £2,504. Hang on a moment, £2,504 after I deposited £2,400 in a year, that's only £104 interest, that's like 4.33%! Shouldn't I earn like £192? I'd be better off using something like a 5% easy access account like [this](https://www.barclays.co.uk/savings/instant-access/rainy-day-saver/).

And so the word spreads - "Regular Savers don't *really* pay what they say" - so people don't look at them.

There are some situations where this is *almost* true. If you have £2,400 right now earning no interest, and your plan is to use the Nationwide Flex Regular Saver as your account of choice for that £2,400, then yes you will only earn an effective interest rate of 4.33%. But this is a terrible idea for what will hopefully become obvious reasons

​

**Interest is earned based on the rate offered and how long you keep money there**

Fixed-Term savings accounts obfuscate how savings really work.

With a fixed-term savings account, you put in an amount of money, you wait a year, and then you get your money back plus that amount multiplied by the advertised interest rate. For example, this 1 year fixed-term account from [Ford](https://www.fordmoney.co.uk/savings-products/fixed-saver) advertises a rate of 5.95%, and in the info box it says you put £1,000 in, you get £1,059.50 out. Great the maths all checks out there, not like those lying Regular Savers. But what this makes people assume is that all you need is to have some money in an account when it's "interest calculation day", and the bank will gladly look at how much you've got in the account and pay you some percentage of that in interest. And that's not what's happening. Despite what terms like "maturity date" might lead you to believe.

This logic leads people to thinking they can outsmart the banks by moving their money around from one "interest calculation day" to another. And the banks aren't that stupid.

How interest actually works is the banks look at your balance **every day**, and they calculate a **daily** amount of interest earned on that balance using a daily interest rate. They keep doing this until it's time to pay you the interest you've accrued. Both the Nationwide and Ford examples pay yearly, so Nationwide and Ford are keeping track of how much interest you've accrued every day and pay you all of that in one go after a year. So the 8% and 5.95% interest rate quoted are accurate over the course of a year once you aggregate up all the daily interest accrual.

If you went for a 6 months fixed-term account, this would become a bit clearer. This account from [Monument](https://www.monument.co/savings/fixed-term-deposits) is a 6 month fix with an advertised interest rate of 5.65%, and their info box says after putting £1,000 in and waiting 6 months you'd have £1,028.25. Hey look, £28.25 is half of £56.5 and £56.5 is what the interest should be if I earned 5.65% interest on £1,000. And you did earn 5.65% interest on your £1,000, but you only kept the money in there for half a year so only got half what you might have expected.

​

**So what does this stupid AER number mean if I can't just multiply it by the amount I save**

AER is designed to make it easier to compare the rates your getting from different savings accounts. And while it might not sound very useful for comparisons when I start to explain it, the more you think about it the more useful it becomes.

AER stands for Annual Equivalent Rate, and what it means is if you put £1 into the account on day 1, and withdrew your whole balance a year later (day 366), what % would your money have grown by. Fords helpful easy example works here, you put in £1,000, after a year you got £1,059.5, so you earned £59.50 on your £1,000 after 1 year, your money grew by 5.95%, you had a 5.95% AER.

This is exactly the same for Nationwide's Regular Saver, but is hidden by the fact that the amount in your account changes over time. If you put £200 into the account on day 1, and didn't touch it or add anything else until day 366, you'd have £216. £16 growth on a £200 starting amount is 8%, you had an 8% AER.

And this is why regular savers aren't lying about the rate they offer. If you put £200 into the Ford account, after 1 year you'd have gained £11.90 in interest. And we've already worked out you'd earn £16 from Nationwide. So for amounts permitted within the account, Nationwide does pay a higher rate than Ford. They just limit how much you can put in there and when.

So if you are happy with the terms of the regular saver - i.e. you only have or want to put £200 aside each month, then your choice between Nationwide and Ford is easy, Nationwide has a higher AER. We should probably stop using Ford as an example now, because Ford actually won't let you add more money over time, and most fixed-term savers work this way. From now on we'll use the [Barclay's Rainy Day](https://www.barclays.co.uk/savings/instant-access/rainy-day-saver/) saver I mentioned about an hour ago (5.12%, easy access, good times).

​

**Ok I get that interest is accrued over time, but regular savers still don't seem worth it**

This is a way more relevant and personal question. To be honest, if I had £200 to put away each month for some savings goal, I'd bite anyone's hand off for 8%. Even if that 8% "only" amounts to a grand total of £104 interest over the course of a year. 8% is 8%, and if my alternative is 0% in a current account, I'm going to take the 8% even if I have to get a new account with a new bank (and even if that bank still uses a card reader...). For me, £104 is worth it, and even just being able to say "I'm earning 8% risk free" is worth it! But for some people it might not be worth the hassle, and it especially might not be worth the hassle if you're already getting 5.12% in an easy access account. Below is a table of how much you'd earn after 1 year in various scenarios putting £200 aside each month:

​

|Account|AER|Interest earned| |:-|:-|:-| |Random current account|0%|£0| |Barclays Rainy Day|5.12%|£66.56| |Nationwide Flex Regular Saver|8%|£104|

​

Now it's even less worth it. If you already have a Barclays Rainy Day account, well it's only worth £37.44 to open up a new account and save for a year. For me (a very tight person) I'm still going for it. That's a free Nandos every year.

Worth pointing out the above is true regardless of how much you already have saved in the easy access account. Some people might think "well if I already have £10k in my easy access account, if I add £200 to it I'll be earning more than if I put £200 in an account with a starting balance of £0". And that's not how it works. You're earning whatever the interest rate is on that new £200 contribution, it doesn't matter how much you already have.

​

**What if I have an existing lump sum of savings rather than new monthly savings**

The results of this scenario might surprise you, as I would have instinctively assumed this be a closer race than it. So we've established above that for *new* savings within the deposit terms of regular savers, they're normally a good choice if they're paying a better rate than other options (assuming the withdrawal terms work for you). When you already have savings however, regular savers can still be a good choice.

So let's say you have £2,400 already and don't intend to contribute any more. You could slowly move it into a regular saver each month, but we've already established because interest is paid based on time in the account, that you're wasting loads of cash sat earning no interest (after month 1 you have £200 earning interest and £2,200 not earning interest). You could put all of it into an easy access account, but you might be missing out on a better rate somewhere else. You could do both - put the full £2,400 into easy access and then slowly move that into the regular saver. Here are some worked examples:

​

|Strategy|Interest earned|Calculated AER| |:-|:-|:-| |Current account and save in regular saver (0% & 8%)|£104|4.33%| |Easy access account only (5.12%)|£122.88|5.12%| |Easy access account and save in regular saver (5.12% & 8%)|£160.32|6.68%|

​

In this scenario, it's worth £37.44 to slowly syphon funds into the regular saver. Which is the same as when we were comparing new deposits to the easy access/regular saver. So the thought process is the same - is it worth £37.44 to open up an additional account over and above an existing saver you have.

Personally I'm on team regular saver. I'm already opening up a million accounts with different banks to get the switching bonuses, so I might as well capitalise on an accessible interest rate even if there's a bit of admin to set up some standing orders.

​

**Bonus question 1: Why don't banks just quote a daily interest rate for comparison instead of AER**

There are two answers to this.

One is because the numbers would look stupid. An 8% AER account that pays interest yearly has a daily interest rate of 0.02192%. Personally I think most people would rather compare 8% and 5.95% rather than 0.02192% and 0.01630%.

The second answer is linked to compounding periods, which I'll explain below.

​

**Bonus question 2: Isn't it better to get interest paid daily/monthly rather than yearly**

So this relates to compounding, and some people who read above that interest is calculated daily probably already started thinking about this.

If you had the choice between getting paid 0.02192% interest every day, or the bank calculating 0.02192% interest every day but only paying out once a year, you'd obviously rather get paid daily right? And yes that's true, if you could get the same daily interest rate, then the more regularly you get paid that interest the better, because as soon as you get paid then that interest can start earning interest. This is what compounding is - interest earning interest.

But again, the banks have already thought about this. AER already takes into account compounding periods and the impact that has on 1 year of returns. So for example, the 8% Nationwide pays out annually, so it's super simple to work out the daily interest - it's just 8% divided by 365. Whereas for something like NatWest, who have a 6.17% regular saver that pays out monthly, their daily rate *isn't* 6.17% divided by 365.

— 0