Okay, my turn to beg for better posts
Let's be real: we have a few of the same people posting pretty much garbage over and over and over again. What are you incredibly tired of seeing? What would you like to propose we see at least significantly less of?
My preference: 1) You have to perform a basic Google search if you're going to ask a question first. I'm trying to not name names, but we've had some questions that betray a basic lack of....a lot of knowledge. Everyone here probably wants to learn, but some of this is too basic, and if you have that big a knowledge gap, you may not be ready to participate in sub discussions. I'm talking things like "Why didn't George IV lead troops into battle as Prince of Wales," or, "Why was Victoria short when other members of her family were tall?" Why don't you try doing some research on your own before you post that one? It'll be good for you, I promise.
2) Impossible to answer "what ifs." "What if X didn't die? What if Y didn't happen?" And what if I was President of Mars? This isn't a speculative history sub, and these questions are impossible to discuss in any real substance, because there's too many other factors involved.
3) This is more of a commenter issue, but I'm really sick of the people in comments (mostly for current royals) coming in and telling us "Why are you even talking about these inbred people? You know they wouldn't have anything to do with you COMMON people, right?" Uh, yeah. I'm not a royalist. I just like history. This isn't the gotcha you think it is and you're being an asshole.
4) On that note, how many times do we have to hear about how inbred So-and-so was? We know. This was a common practice throughout the entire WORLD. Do you know how many Japanese emperors married their nieces? If you can't handle the squick, maybe this isn't the spot for you. It's not like anyone here is waving a "Yay, cousin marriage!" sign. It was an accepted practice in that time and place. (In some places, it still is.)
5) I'm willing to bend on this one, but "Who's better, X or Y," or"Who's your favorite?" are pretty low hanging fruit to me. It's either a pretty obvious answer (that the OP then argues about for some reason), or you just say who you like and there's really nothing to discuss.
I like a lot of the posts in this sub where people put time, thought, and energy into talking about people in their broader geographical and historic contexts, the effects their personalities had on the world around them, etc.. but these other types of posts and comments are getting incredibly obnoxious, and I would love to see that stamped out somewhat.
There's my grumpy post, what's yours?
EDIT: aw! Thanks for the award! I'm glad to see other people are feeling this, I would really love to see this sub get cleaned up a bit. Maybe we need a second moderator?