RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/Ubiquiti • … • u/cooper_trav

UniFi Express, my first Ubiquiti experience, has been very disappointing

So, first of all, some back story. I had been using a Google Wifi mesh network for about 10 years, and decided it was time for a change. I have Ethernet in every room in my house, so I had the Google units hardwired. For the past few months, I'd notice the network glitching for a few seconds here or there, so I decided it was time to replace them.

I went to r/HomeNetworking and started searching around and saw that Ubiquiti was recommended over and over again. So I started looking at the products. They looked good, but I wasn't sure that I was ready to spend all the money it would take to replace my router and the APs, so I just kind of kept looking. Then, that week, the UniFi Express was released. It looked like it could meet my needs, and also let me slowly start building into the Ubiquiti ecosystem without as much up front cost. So, I ordered three of them.

This is my current configuration. Modem->UniFi. UniFi->unmanaged switch. Other two UniFi devices connected to the switch, both of them also use the other LAN port for a couple of downstream devices. I found, and turned off, all meshing, so they should be forced to be using the LAN connection for backhauling (I realize these aren't great devices for Meshed WiFi backhauling).

Now, on to my experience. First off, I tried to set up all the UniFi devices before replacing my old mesh network. I got them all configured and everything seemed to be good. I went to switch out all the Google devices with the UniFi devices and they just wouldn't start up. They'd hang for a really long time. One of them I waited for over 10 minutes before giving up. Ultimately, I had to factory reset the devices and then reconfigure them. So, this was a bit weird, but I figured it would be okay.

A couple of days later, one of my devices that was inside an entertainment console, didn't seem to be performing poorly, the console showed me that the devices connected to it were having a good experience, instead of an excellent experience. Even devices pretty near by. So, I decided to move the unit outside the cabinet (my old google mesh device was also inside the cabinet and never had issues). I simply unplugged it, moved it outside, then plugged it back in. Well, the same thing happened when I first tried to place all the units, it just wouldn't connect back up to the network. Eventually I gave up and just factory reset it and reconnected it again.

Now I'm starting to wonder why they can't just reconnect. I decided to just restart the other device, that is acting as an AP, from within the console. Through that restart, the same thing, it never connected. Again, I had to reset the device then re-add it.

I finally reached out to support, and so far it hasn't been great. They first told me it was because I had a loop in my network, and meshing can sometimes cause that. When I told them that meshing was turned off, then they said it is probably because I'm using an unmanaged switch, and I should buy a ubiquiti switch to make them work properly. I finally got them to pass this along to the next level of support, but they are basically just telling me to try something and send them the logs. I try it, send them logs, have to then reset my devices and reconnect them again, then wait for them to tell me they still don't know what is going on. So, then they ask me to try something else, rinse and repeat. It is starting to get very annoying.

Then, about two weeks ago, the console got it's first automatic update. We were away on vacation at the time, so when we got back several days later, I noticed things seemed off. I logged into the console, and it showed the console disconnecting multiple times per day, right after the update happened. Luckily I was able to connect directly (it wasn't working through the normal website), in order to see this, and it had a restart button. So, I restarted it and it was able to reconnect. I was happy that I didn't have to factory reset this main device, but it definitely took a long time to restart, like 5 minutes.

Now, for the past two weeks, I'll just try to log in to the console from time to time, and it just won't ever load. Even though Internet is working fine on all my devices, so it just looks like the console management is the issue. I finally connect to it and restart the main device, and it will start back up, then in the activity bars for devices, Internet, etc. they all show no activity for the past 8, or 12 hours. I look in the logs and there is nothing showing up. So, the console is just going down randomly and there is no indication of what is causing it.

Overall, I have had more problems in \~3 weeks with these devices than I did in 10 years with my Google mesh network. I have to believe that there wouldn't be so many recommendations for Ubiquiti if all the products were this bad. But I'm definitely not impressed so far. I'm hoping it is just because they are so new, and there are bugs that need to be worked out, but I'm only going to have patience for so long, then I'll switch back to my Google WiFi.

— 0