RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/Veritasium • … • u/Assume_Utopia

Is Derek trying to lure another professor in to making and losing a $10k bet with the "The Big Misconception About Electricity" video?

I can't understand how Derek would make and publish a video that covers such an interesting and important topic, and make the main claim only technically true according to a very weird set of definitions and assumptions. And then demonstrate it with a real battery and real switch and real lightbulb that comes on to full brightness immediately, which is not what would actually happen according to every other expert that's weighed in.

If I'm being charitable, then it feels like the channel got a lot of attention and views when he made the Blackbird video. And having that kind of video that generates a lot of discussion about a very unintuitive result is a great way to get more views and get more people to talk about the topic, etc. For example, the Helicopter Rope Riddle was another video that was very similar to the original Blackbird video.

I don't actually think anyone would bet him $10k again, since he was so careful to cover his bases by clearly defining terms like "on" in a way that would be technically correct. And also not clearly explaining what the actual results of the experiment would look like if it was possible to carry it out. But I'm sure if someone did, that would be a great result for the channel, at least from an "engagement" perspective.

And it does seem like Derek has been doing *a lot* of experimentation with the channel. Changing titles and thumbnails to try and see what effects it has on views, including making a whole video about how effective clickbait is. I wouldn't be terribly surprised if the "Big Misconception About Electricity" video was some kind of social experiment to see if making a video that was technically true, but somewhat deceiving would be good for traffic.

— 0