Vampire 5th Edition and why I'm worried....
So, I've been a Vampire/World of Darkness fan since the middle of the 90's. V:tm 2nd Edition was the first RPG I ever played, back in 1995, so Vampire and to a lesser extent Werewolf have always been amongst my favorite RPG's.
I was ecstatic and ohh so happy when I heard that Paradox Interactive had bought White Wolf from CCP. I'm a big Paradox fan, CK2 and EU4 are brilliant computer games. I saw videos of them talking about the new Vampire and everything sounded cool, dark and gritty, just like I like my Vampire.
But then the V5 alpha test came out and with it my disappointment. I don't like the new blood usage rules at all....
I feel that the new system requires more book-keeping then the old system and it increases the number of dice rolls in a system I feel would benefit from fewer dice rolls.
But the thing I dislike the most is that vampires now gets hungry a lot faster, like a whole fucking mega lot faster. In the old system there was tons of disciplines you could activate without using your blood reserves, Gleam of Red Eyes, Feral Whispers, Spirit's Touch, Eyes of Chaos, Mesmerize and a whole lot more. Now, every single activation of a discipline potentially makes you hungrier, which requires you to go feeding.
Feeding is an area that White Wolf wants to highlight, it's the very in-your-face sign that you are playing a monster. You are what you eat and all that. I like the idea of it, but in actuality feeding is the most boring time of play... The spotlight is on one player, since feeding is mostly a private thing, so the other players just have to sit there while the GM solo plays with the feeding player. (sure, they could portray supporting characters and the like, but still). The first couple of times in a campaign that a character goes feeding, it might make sense to play it out, it's a good character development tool, but when you are 2-3 years into a campaign, heck, even just a couple of months into a campaign feeding becomes boring and takes time away from the actual story.
The focus on feeding might work well in small contained stories or scenarios, but in campaigns I feel it quickly gets old and boring. I just want it over with so we can get back to the story....
TL:DR I feel that the new Vampire places to much emphasis on feeding/hunting, taking away to much focus from the actual story.