NTC Rewards are reworked; They weren't actually the problem.
The problem is what the rewards were for the amount of effort, time, and money being demanded. We know that premium ships are often buffs to parts of free ships at the cost of being worse in one area or another-- usually something less important. We know that premium ships often provide strength profiles that no other ship can draw a comparison to, effectively offering unique tools.
Offering premium ships through the NTC with the same absurd method of acquisition is simply trading one kind of buff and power for another. If ship upgrades and commander skills were locked behind a functional paywall like re-grinding 8 lines, we wouldn't play the game. If they were locked out unless you had premium time, we wouldn't play the game. And when Stalingrad first showed up offering tools no other ship had and was confined to only a few players until the Steel and Coal systems arrived with the Armory to rectify this accessibility problem, many rioted and stopped playing the game. Ship upgrades and commander skills are acceptable strengths and buffs because they are accessible to any player willing to acquire them for a reasonable amount of effort-- leveling a commander, purchasing upgrades with Coal or credits, or working towards a unique.
**The fundamental issue with the NTC was not that it offered buffs, but that it offered buffs** ***the vast majority of players could never hope to reasonably acquire.*** If they were readily available in some sort of "Elite" system that ***any*** player could reasonably work towards with just a bit of effort, they would still impact overall game balance and meta, but they wouldn't create a divide between the haves and have-nots. ***Strong premium ships under the same circumstances will have the same effects.*** They will only be fair if the method of acquiring them is fair.
Huge kudos to WG for responding quickly and expressing an obvious desire to make players happen and listen to their concerns. For us, the players, though: we need to identify the real issue. **Gameplay effects** *and* **reasonable acquisition thereof** ***works.*** We have examples of this. **Non-gameplay effects like cosmetics** *and* **"unreasonable" acquisition thereof** ***also works.*** We have examples of this, too, like Clan/Ranked token camos, or $30+ ship skins.
**Gameplay effects** *and* **"unreasonable" acquisition thereof** does ***not*** work. Whether those effects are buffs, or ships that are functionally buffs to other ships, or ships that are functionally buffs to a player's or clan's toolkit because there are no other ships directly competing with it. NTC will only work if the incredibly unreasonable, punishing, pay-to-clear grind to acquire the rewards is accompanied with non-gameplay rewards whether buffs or ships, ***or*** the effort and the mechanics involved are made reasonable and fair. I think everybody generally likes the idea of an end-stage system with fun gameplay stuff to work towards, and thus the mechanisms involved in acquiring those things need to be the primary focus.
Don't get hung up on "it's not buffs any more, it's ships instead". The real problem was the other half of the equation, and that hasn't changed yet.
​
***TL;DR:*** All that's changed is instead of re-grinding a line *half a dozen times* to make a ship you like better, you're just doing it to get a better ship.