RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/XWingTMG • … • u/SonOfShem

Thoughts on AMG's design philosophy for X-wing

I've been giving this a bit of thought recently. It seems that a lot of the changes that AMG is making to this game are intended to make skill and experience less relevant, so that newer players do not have to spend as long losing games before they learn the game properly and start winning.

And I realized that this was very similar to a discussion that was had when Star Wars: Fallen Order came out.

Much like Dark Souls, Fallen Order had a very punishing combat system. Unless you played on Story Mode, fights were challenging, and if you played on Master or Grand Master difficulties, the game was downright punishing.

This made the game difficult. You had to put a ton of time into the game to be good at it. You had to learn your enemies attack patterns: when to block, when to dodge, and when to attack.

But the advantage of this is that you truly got a sense of pride and accomplishment (and not the kind you pay for \*cough\*EA\*cough\*). You worked hard, but once you had developed the skills you felt like a jedi: reading your opponents attacks and perfectly responding to them accordingly.

I think FFG's X-wing was along the same lines. It was a hard game if you were playing a skilled opponent. And you would reliably get your ass handed to you if they were more skilled than you. But when you did beat someone you could often feel like you out-flew them.

Of course, this often comes at the expense of someone else, who made those poor decisions and allowed you to win. But the core idea is that you should feel like skill has a massive part to play, because when it does then you can feel rewarded for your accomplishments.

AMG's focus on newer players and making the game easier for them undermines this value. People still play dark souls today, because beating it is an accomplishment worth putting effort in to obtain. You don't see the same sort of life with the lego starwars games, for example. They have to constantly put new ones out because once you've beaten the game and gotten all your collectables, there's nothing more to do. Any replay value is nostalgia driven, rather than driven by interest in the game.

So, if I had the ear of AMG's design team for a minute, I would say that the solution for newer players is not to strip the game of its skill requirements, but to develop a series of official handicaps that players can offer each other if they perceive a large skill gap.

If I (an almost exclusively casual player who started not long before the pandemic) am playing the 5 time store champ with 8 years experience, I would love it if AMG had published an official list of things he can offer me something that levels the playing field a bit, without chaining the core mechanics. Maybe I can have a 2 dial re-do's, where I get to re-set my dial on my ships initiative if they bumped. Maybe I get a free focus when I bump. Maybe all my ships have 1 extra hull and shield. Maybe I get an extra 50 points to list build with.

This could mitigate the experience gap without eliminating the ability for high level players to compete. Heck, it might make for a fun tournament style, where highly skilled players see if they can out-fly newer players with very large handicaps. They get to stretch their skill to the limits, while newer players feel like they still have a shot.

— 0