RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/ageofsigmar • … • u/Snuffleupagus03

How are people interpreting Myrmourn Banshees' Spell-eaters ability

This is an example of a complicated rule, and I really can't believe they didn't have an FAQ ready to go on this one. I have a seen a few discussions on it, with a wide variety of interpretations in various circumstances.

I'm really wondering what people think and how you're playing it at your tables?

>"Spell-eaters" says: > >You can roll 2d6 each time an enemy Wizard successfully casts a spell that is not unbound and chooses for the effect of the spell to apply to a unit wholly within 12" of this unit, or when an endless spell finishes a move within 6" of this unit. Add 1 to the roll of this unit has 3 or more models. If the roll is greater than the casting value for that spell or endless spell, that spell is unbound before it has any effect or that endless spell is dispelled.

So the couple issues that come up:

1. What does "chooses for the effect of the spell ..." exactly mean? Why not just say "effects a unit wholly within 12"?" which is how spell shrug bubbles are worded. One interpretation is that this doesn't stop 'area' spells. So if a spell does something to every unit within an area, is the casting player "choosing" to effect a unit? If not, then when does this 'choosing' language make a difference? 2. What happens with the order of effects when an endless spell lands. It lands and now its effect and the banshee dispel are simultaneous, so will the endless spell still have an effect on the controlling players turn? That doesn't seem to be RAI, but they put "before it has any effect" before they put "or that endless spell is dispelled." Unfortunately, that suggests endless spells could have an effect. 3. What happens when an endless spell lands outside 6" but effects a unit that is wholly within 12"? It is a spell choosing to effect a unit, but not as a result of the spell being successfully cast, rather it is the result of the endless spell moving.

Are there other weird interactions you've seen? This seems like a cool idea of a rule, but just full of annoying interactions that aren't clear from the wording.

— 0