AI Art should be held to a higher standard
I am very aware that AI art (visual, music, written, etc) is not going anywhere, no matter your opinion on the subject. A lot of how we judge art is based on the idea that we understand that it is made by a fallible human with limited abilities. Really good for a 6th grader is different from really good for a pro with 20 years in the field.
AI essentially aggregates all the time one would spend learning and developing a skill into seconds of work. Therefore, I propose that AI art should be held to a much, much higher standard than traditional art. A lot of the AI art I’ve seen has been good on a technical level, but has been uninspired and simplistic, or been boring. I shouldn’t have to give an AI artist the same grace as a traditional artist given the capabilities of the tools they have. If a creator doesn’t have to have skills to make something, then the judgement of that thing should be against the best it can do. If an AI piece isn’t amazing by traditional standards then it should get no praise. If AI is just a tool, then what it produces should be measured against what the tool can do. One should not be considered an AI artist until they have mastered it and can produce things worthy of the capability of the medium.