AI & Published Work
I would consider myself fairly pragmatic in terms of AI. I think it's a tool that should be used responsibly. However, I have noticed an argument in the gun ho side of this issue that basically claims that an artist should not post something publicly (online) without accepting the risk that it will be AI trained on. To me, this seems ridiculous for several reasons, but maybe I do not understand the situation.
\- Why would online spaces be considered public spaces and why would this be defacto consent for the use of your image for commercial purposes?
\- Why should art posted well before the AI boom be anticipating that their data could be scraped? In other words, why would and should an artist fifteen years ago just be expected to waive their rights?
\- With respect to laws e.g., the right to be forgotten / erasure, there are cases where images of people , etc. are posted without permission and then are taken down. It seems to me a gross violation of data protection for AI to be trained on images like these as they necessarily can be erased as a legal right in the EU. Is it not? Is this a blind spot?
\- If public access is treated as consent for AI training, then what logic justifies commercial use of other public posted work? e.g., if I'm an academic and just refuse to cite, only paraphrase, etc. We draw ethical lines normally regarding imitation, intellectual property, and so on.