I don't care as much about random social media posts. But if AI art is being used to sell, advertise, or market something, disclosure should be mandatory.
I understand the argument that some AI artists choose not to disclose their use of AI because they fear being harassed or bullied off platforms.
However, once you start selling artwork, advertising products, or making money from AI-generated content, non-disclosure becomes a very different issue. At that point, consumers have a reasonable expectation to know how the work was created. Hiding AI involvement can easily cross into deceptive marketing and undermine trust in online marketplaces.
Part of why I feel this way is because I used to buy genuinely handcrafted products on Etsy. Today, Etsy and TikTok are flooded with listings and advertisements that use AI-generated images in ways that can mislead buyers about what they're actually purchasing.
If we're looking for AI regulations that both Pro and Anti AI could potentially agree on, mandatory disclosure of materially AI-generated content in commercial advertising and sales seems like a reasonable place to start. It doesn't restrict people from using AI. It simply gives consumers the transparency needed to make informed decisions.
**Edit:** Many of the arguments in this thread have pointed out that AI itself may not be the root problem, but rather manipulation and deception more broadly which regulation could address. I think that’s a fair point and has shifted my perspective somewhat.
That said, I still think AI-specific disclosure requirements can be worth considering in certain contexts. AI dramatically increases the scale and accessibility of synthetic content, and we’re already seeing policymakers grapple with that distinction. For example, New York recently passed a law requiring disclosure of AI-generated “synthetic performers” in advertising. Whether those policies are ultimately the right approach is up for debate, but I don’t think the discussion itself is unreasonable.