RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/aiwars • … • u/step_uneasily

Don't Call Us Luddites for Demanding Ethical AI

I wouldn’t have such a problem with AI and datacenters if it all hadn't been implemented and continues to be handled so fucking greedily. And I doubt it could’ve happened any other way given the capitalist, borderline-corporatist hellscape we’re trapped in. And I'm not even a commie (just maybe a little Swedish).

I mean, capitalism could so easily be done properly and fairly but it isn’t, which is why I hate it. AI could be handled responsibly and scientifically but it isn’t, which is why I hate it. And for those of you saying that things will calm down, that regulations will come once the dust settles etc.: I mean, no it absolutely will not, not without a fight. Not if the people don’t protest and demand protections of our rights, legal and economic transparency, proper labels and ethical land development from the men holding the AI:s "captive". And while they're at it, how about they (*large ass corporations*) drop the feigned ignorance and start to actually compensate those (*individual households ffs*) whose electrical bills have gone through the roof all because of those pestilential (yeah [^(1)](https://news.ncsu.edu/2026/05/data-centers-power-bills/), [^(2)](https://eelp.law.harvard.edu/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Harvard-ELI-Extracting-Profits-from-the-Public.pdf), [^(3)](https://www.brookings.edu/articles/confronting-and-addressing-rising-energy-bills-linked-to-data-centers/), [^(4)](https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/jun/08/datacenter-ai-drought-water), [^(5)](https://avanzaenergy.substack.com/p/who-pays-the-hidden-economics-of), [^(etc)](https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/action/downloadSupplement?doi=10.1029%2F2025AV002140&file=2025AV002140-sup-0001-Original+Version+of+Manuscript-S01.pdf)...) and freeloading-ass (yup, [^(1)](https://unu.edu/inweh/news/environmental-cost-of-AIs-Enrgy-use-carbon-water-and-land-footprints)^(,) [^(2)](https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2025AV002140)^(,) [^(3)](https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2025AV002140)^(,) [^(4)](https://thesustainableagency.com/blog/environmental-impact-of-generative-ai/)^(,) [^(etc)](https://collections.unu.edu/eserv/UNU:10647/UNU-INWEH-Report-The_Env_Cost_of_AI-2026.pdf)...) datacenters? They don't even have the decency to pay for their shit themselves? Countrymen have overthrown entire monarchies for way less, you know.

instead of just labelling us as ”hysterical luddite antis” and pretty much invalidate all of our criticisms/concerns by default, why aren’t the rest of you joining us in demanding this all be done properly instead? I'm not saying this to all "pro-AI people", but some, I suppose.

Surely we all want things to improve for all? Just makes inherent sense that we do. But believe me when I say that it's just not going to get done without some proper mad fury. Because clearly people are pissed. But please, just try not to conflate that anger you see in people right now - *the justifiable kind -* with us simply being stuck in the past or "afraid of change" or other weird claims like that. Just makes me think you (those of you) don't even try to listen to our points, and just see us as some sort of obstructionist saboteurs or whatever. I'm actually pretty sure that for many of us AI sceptics or "Antis", these corrupt practices are just dealbreakers for us. Most of us even, I'd wager (IRL that is, perhaps less-so URL). And that goes both ways, for sure. I'll get a bit more into that later on tbf.

This anger kind of tracks though, doesn't it? I mean it's essentially just how ideas and awareness are expressed in and shared between humans. Like, if someone really does not condone the industry that's behind fabricating a certain thing, then chances are they'd also be turned off from *the* *thing* itself, regardless of how much they could've enjoyed it had it been made differently. To that end, I'd absolutely argue that we'd see way less of the fierce, grassroots-backlash from people that we see today, if just the product itself hadn't been so haphazardly and ethically irresponsibly unleashed on the world - if the ones at the reigns of this "revolution" (calling it that kind of pisses me off seeing as the ones actually revolting as it were are multi-billionaire antisocial freaks) would've had the slightest bit of decency to run it by us first, introduce it step by step perhaps, *anything* but how they did it.

And at the time it really didn't sit right with me and countless other people who hitherto had enjoyed uploading our art and music to the internet for years thinking it was safe and *ours* alone. But out of fucking nowhere generative AI comes along and we're told that corpos have been touching and rubbing their dicks up against our shit for years without us knowing. I exaggerate obvs. But it did kinda *feel* like theft, that I can tell you. Now, I might not have felt all that if they'd just taken the time out of their schedule to present it all to us in a more transparent, people-friendly manner. A lot of us probably wouldn't have. Know what I mean?

So how to realistically bring about change? 'Cause our dear and presently raging sociopaths at the top of all this won’t do shit of their own volition unless someone (someones, together, preferably) walk the walk and force their hands. To bring about changes in regulation, ethical and environmental responsibility, etc, etc. - changes that benefit all of us. Are for all of us, artists and AI-artists alike. Let’s maybe do that instead of degrading ourselves to pointless bickering all the time (guilty of this too, myself). 'Cause I mean, ultimately all that accomplishes is that it cements us further as a divided demographic and turns us infinitely more susceptible to manipulation and populism and all that jazz. .On that note I'm actually so fed-up with USA’s borderline-compulsive tendency to split things by the middle and use a two-point/good vs evil duality reference guide for absolutely everything, which is starting to take over the rest of the whole wide-western world now too. Albeit slightly endearing in some contexts, It’s mainly such a telltale sign of that nation's imperialistic adolescence (proverbially speaking, for you lovely misconstruers out there). Perhaps a short bout of fascism is just what it'll have to take for that bratty superpower to snap out of it, so to speak. Sorry and I'll move on.

I’m a through-and-through science fiction literature, film and video game geek as well as really into technological/scientific advancements and the like, so in theory I’d be super excited about this whole ”AI revolution”. It’s truly mindblowing tech. Yet, in an excruciatingly predictable turn of events, it has been handled fucking atrociously and I frankly cannot consciously support any of that shit until they get their act together as it were.

That will naturally take a long-ass time seeing how ensnared generative AI has become in not only our everyday lives but in our whole contemporaneous economic system which as we all know and love incentivises profit over quality of life for the needy/the consumer/minorities/literally anyone except the ones hoarding the $$.

# Will AI ever truly escape the clutches of corporate avarice? And further, will We ever escape the clutches of an AI owned and plenarily governed by a detached bunch of shamelessly despotic motherfuckers?

Man, we could’ve been so much more than this. Mankind should’ve listened more to the thinkers and less to their own inner narcissists. This is currently not a future I’ll ever subscribe to.

And just for the sake of transparency/bias concession: I am harbouring a four-year, student-debt-up-the-wazoo Music Production degree that I can’t really see leading to any sort of music related starting positions anytime soon seeing as… well they apparently don't fucking exist anymore!

I suppose AI along with the nature of late-stage capitalism/older generations neglecting to leave the door open for the coming generations/whatever has completely evaporated any feasible, financially realistic music career paths. Idk it really didn’t look like that when I started studying is all; and by the time I got my ”magisterexamen” (Swedish degree roughly equating a Master's), it was well into 2022 and, well, that sort of speaks for itself at this point. I had a pretty ominous fucking feeling those last few years though, even wrote my finishing thesis on AI music around that time, did a bunch of interviews with emerging artists, and boy did we have no idea of how insane things were just about to start getting. It’s like I graduated into another word for real.

I’m almost at the point of dreaming of a total worldwide economic reset to perhaps sort some of these discrepancies out, but that’d of course prerequisite a French Revolution type event so I’m not holding my breath on our lazy asses to get the job done lol.

\_\_\_\_\_\_\_ Right, done. Got a little, kinda, pretty damn long-winded there, sorry about that. I doubt anyone's read this far anyway lol. But as a finishing footnote in case you actually have:  I’m  sure there are lots of completely decent, wholesome, intelligent and non-toxic pro AI people here. I am not directing any indignation towards you, I just want everyone to know this so we can avoid talking over each other and not give misconstrued animosity a chance. On that note within this finishing footnote, I might not be able to reply very readily right now as I got uni in a bit but anyway, cheers until such time.

— 0