RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/anime • … • u/cliffy117

Most disappointing sequels for you?

To give a bit of context: I've been on a Mecha anime crave lately, so I've been rewatching some shows while watching the ongoing anime season.

Finished Gunbuster 3 days ago. I hadn't watched it in about 15 years and I'm glad to say, it still hold up. I gave it a 9/10 back then and I'm giving it a 9/10 now. Fantastic short series with a masterful ending.

However, back then I did not watch Diebuster. So I thought "Let's correct that mistake now!". Oh boy. I wish I hadn't done it. I guess I saw some reviews or videos about it back then and that's why I skipped it. Not this time, I jumped straight into it with a smile and excitement.

Really, this post is mostly just so I can vent. I just finished Diabuster. And it is without a doubt in my mind one of the worst and most disrespectful sequels I've ever seen. Worse than something like Promised Neverland S2 only because, as trash as that one was, it didn't shit on S1 nor made it worse. Diebuster shits all over Gunbuster and shits all over its masterful ending. I'm pissed.

Gunbuster tried to stay grounded and explain why things worked the way they did, and it used real concepts like time dilatation and used them as plot points to push the narrative. Diebuster shits all over that. It tries to explain nothing. They move from planet to planet back and forth and no one ever ages, travel time and time itself was not a concept fo the writers. At one point the MC is on a mission to Pluto, she's going there, while everyone else is on Mars or around there and they all see the events and react to them at the same time despise info and travel, even at light speeds, taking weeks at best, months at worst. That's the recurrent issue of the anime: Things happen. Why they happen, how they happen, what are the consequences of it? Who cares. Space magic. And, to remind, S1, Gunbuster, did try to stay grounded, time is literally a plot point to showcase how much the characters are giving up: They are leaving their love ones for several years, decades, giving they whole lives to save Humanty. Diebuster gives 0 fucks about that.

Gunbuster was all about how, with effort, everyone could achieve their dreams, even a weak and fearful person, like Noriko, could achieve greatness with dedication and with friends. Diebuster shits all over that, you need to be born with some magic space bullshit to pilot mechas, which are now biomechanical weapons with personalities and feelings that can also full on break reality because of why the fuck not.

Gunbuster put emphais into 3 characters, but mostly Noriko. This is one of its weaknesses, but Noriko is well developed, so It can be exused. Diebuster gives some characters their own episode. That would be an improvement if not for the fact that they suck at best, make no sense at worst. Like [Diebuster Spoilers]>! the girl who hated snow because the person she loved died when it was snowing and since she couldn't save him then now she hated... herself? being a space wizzar- I mean "Topless"? Who know and who cares, she's never, ever relevant at all to the story despise wastig a whole episode in a 6 episodes series, to her. Then you have a character just try to rape Nono out of nowhere and.. yeah, that also goes nowhere good because, you don't see that character again until the end and for like 5 seconds, and all it does it make one of the other character hate Nono... because. How dare she almost get raped, I guess. Stupid forced drama basically !<

The end is a full on asspull that makes abolsutely no sense and not in a good way.

And here's the thing. I don't mind if anime goes "This is how it is, I can't explain it, but its cool. Take it or leave it". I like Promare and that perfectly describes that movie. Nothing make sense, but that was the point. The writers knew they were just making cool shit to have fun and cool shit to have fun they made. At no point they tried to be anything more nor deeper. Diebuster tries, multiple times at being serious. It is a sequel to a serious and as grounded as a show about mechas could be, be. Yet its ending is bassically Gurren Lagann (my favorite mecha show), but trash.

As its own thing, I could see myself being less harsh, but they made the connection to Gunbuster big enough that if you didn't watch it, you won't understand Diebuster, but also small enough that it feels like they just put on the references last minute to salvage a failed project. Ultimately making it impossible to see Diebuster as its own thing.

So, what sequels or continuations have disappointed you?

— 0