RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/antiai • … • u/FoxyDepression

Getting sick of hearing about "dream" projects

One of the things I see AI users say a lot is that AI is or will allow them to make their "dream" project, usually a game or anime. And the way this kind of project is talked about is very peculiar to me. Just to clarify somethings at the start, I understand dream projects. Plenty of artists, maybe even most, have an ideal creative work they've had in mind since early in their life that they are hoping to one day gain the skills and resources to excecute. There is inherent value to most personal creative projects, but there is something particularly special about projects that people are passionate about or hold close to their heart. And I am more than capable of appreciating and genuinely enjoying ametuer art. I'm sure these AI users dream projects are fun ideas based off of their biggest inspiration that have the potential to be beautiful works of art loved by many people. That all said, the thing about dream projects is that they pretty much all start out bad.

And that's ok. Like I said, this is not a conversation about quality. They're not bad because they're cringe or something. They're bad because they were conceived during adolescence, or young adulthood at most, before people usually have a good grasp on narrative techniques or art principles or game design practices yet. The idea for that dream project often comes from stuff tbe artist first enjoyed, but they probably didn't have an advanced understanding of why they liked those things, what parts worked, what parts didn't, or how to improve those things. You can see people talking about media all the time without a good understanding of just the thing they're talking about. If I heard one more person ask "Why did Rose Quartz have to die to create Steven?" I'm gonna explode. If you go back and look at the first versions of the dream projects that became successful, whether that be through interviews or old online accounts, you can also see that those versions were kind of trash. They often lacked the elements they would later become best known and praised for or had elements that were extremely poorly conceived in hindsight. The reason people carry dream projects for so long isn't necesserily because they're waiting for permission to make it. It's because it takes time to develop great ideas and those projects go through a lot of dramatic changes as people revise them over and over until they can fulfill that projects potential. It's better to view those dream projects as concepts, a starting point and not the end destination. By the end, it will probably be completely different than you imagined

None of that is to say that you shouldn't make your project. The idea that you need to become good enough to make something is lame. On the contrary, you should always try making things you're passionate about because its a great way to grow as an artist. A lot of the things you thought would turn out great will probably look flawed to you looking back but that's how you're able to understand the issues and improve them. Some of the best content online is webcomics started by middle schoolers with very imperfect art that you can watch improve and change over the course of their creation as they get better. And then if they're still passionate about those projects, they usually end up abandoned and restarted because they can do better now. Again, it is an exercise, not a final destination

AI artists put this reverent value on their dream projects. They have some high expectation for what it probably one of their first projects in the beginning of their creative journey that it will be perfect for them. A lot of the dream projects I hear AI users describe fall into common pitfalls of beginner artists. They're often too derivitive. They focus too much on cool factor. Almost all of them have a huge problem with scale. They hang onto bad ideas that they're too attached to let go of. They try to fix common audience complaints without understanding how things came to exist and that they are often unavoidable or necessary for the story/mechanics to work. They see their project from the back end and fail to consider how it will be received by an audience. So on and so forth. But the overall attitude in the AI community is that users are very disinterested in the creative process. They have a poor understanding of the principles of their medium of choice and are generally not interested in learning. Its such that even when they have the potential to make a higher-quality project, they are unable to identify effective elements and make poor creative choices. When you combine all that with the ability to bring those project into existence very quickly the first way they first imagine it, it churns out... well, slop frankly. And the flaws are often glaring to most other artists. I think thats what leads to their conclusion that people's criticism must be coming from bias because they can't see those flaws and thus assume they aren't there.

TL:DR Your dream project is probably shit and perfectly recreating the vision of that project in your head will probably not result in a good final product. That project could be good, but AI will not help you learn the creative process or help you develop your idea to its higher potential. If you want to make good art, you can't skip over the process of learning what good art is and how to make it

— 0