RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/appraisal • … • u/kistner

multiple parcels

I have run in to this many times over the years. Every time it's a hassle.

In this case, we have a separate buildable lot. House sits on an acre, second lot (own parcel number, even has its own address) is also an acre. Separate highest and best uses for each site.

What I have done, which is how FHA likes it, is reference the 2nd parcel but to not actually include it in the valuation. Call it out as excess land. This has worked for nearly all my conventional deals as well.

I have a client who is absolutely demanding I add both sites in, probably because some moron prior to me did so. I told them I can do this, but it isnt market value, its not done to highest and best use. They are arguing that it is highest and best use since the 2nd parcel is tied up in the mortgage and cant be separated. I said that's not part of highest and best use. They are basically demanding i do it 'their way'.

Looking for any insight on how others have handled this. I'd guess if you dont exclusively work in a city it probably comes up once a year or so, like it does for me?

— 0