RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/asoiaf • … • u/Beautiful_Fig_3111

[Spoilers MAIN] Tywin Could not Remarry because of Tyrion's Dwarfism

Was having a conversation with a friend about Tywin's marrage and did some quick search afterwards. I don't see much discussion on this point so thought I might raise this here.

My argument is: **Tywin did not remarry at least partly because of Tyrion's Dwarfism.**

Lady Joanna died in 273 A.D. after which her husband, Lord Tywin at the age of only 31, never remarried despite being a major lord in a realm where nobles marry for political reasons. This became even harder to understand after 281 A.D., when their son Jaime took the White and could not longer inherit the Rock. With Cersei eventually to marry someone else and her children bearing a different house name, Tywin needed to remarry if only to produce another heir, or within the main Lannister line he would have to hand the Rock to the only remaining option, his dwarf son Tyrion, something he swore to prevent.

Yet he never did.

When people talk about this choice, the common points raised often describe how he was in love with Lady Joanna, and how he was hypocritical not to remarry politically but forced his children to do so. *I do not challenge either part of this poin*t. Lord Tywin was likely indeed in love with his wife and he was often a hypocrit. Before 281 A.D., this was likely the explanation.

However, I do think there was another consideration in question post 281 A.D. that a man like Tywin specifically would not miss.

With Joanna died and Tyrion a dwarf, should Tywin choose to remarry, there can only be three possible outcomes:

* He remarried and the new marriage never produced children; * He remarried and none of his new children were dwarf; * He remarried and the new pair gave birth to at least another dwarf child;

All three cases should be unacceptable to a man like Tywin.

In the first case, a childless marriage would be a good source of gossips, especially after 281 A.D. when all would by all reasons expect him to try for more heirs;

In the second case, his new children would further the rumours about Lady Joanna being unfaithful and Tywin being cuckhold, since Tyrion would then truly and unquestionably become the abnormally. We should remember that there were rumours about King Aerys making moves on Lady Joanna. Some questioned if the child was truly his, while others wonder if the child was a punishment by the Gods. If Tywin remarried and ALL his later children were perfectly fine, then it would be announcing that Tyrion was INDEED the different one resulted either from a different seed or the act of adultery.

In the third case, another dwarf would indicate that Tywin himself was the one causing the issue. Having two dwarf children with two different wifes is certainly something that would stir up conversations and a prideful lord like Tywin would not have that.

So from this perspective, Tywin literally *could not* have another go for heir exactly **because however the new children turned out or not, it would be a smear on his, his beloved wife's, and the family honour and offer new fuel to the rumours.**

**New marriage produced fine children? People wonder about Tyrion and Joanna. New marriage produced more dwarfs? People laugh about himself. New marriage with no children? People ask questions.**

Lord Tywin was, above all, a very insecured man who mistrusted all smiles. He could not stand mockery and insults and he never learned how to deal with it. He did not know how to love, how to hate, how to care or even how to whore if the ridiculous secret paths in the Red Keep were indeed his just to fuck. He was a man who never learned to be vulnerable or to allow others to be vulnerable.

In other words, he was exactly the kind of man that would think about and deeply care about these types of things.

He made his own prison really: The only reason he would need another heir was because he could not handle Tyrion's dwarfism and Joanna's death. But he couldn't. For exactly the same reason why he needed more children in the first place: His incapability to look pass Dwarfism and perhaps more importantly, to handle the gossips and laughs behind his back that came with it. A man strong enough to love his dwarf son, or if this is too demanding for a feudal lord, to endure the risks of gossips and laughters to try again, wouldn't see an issue AT ALL.

Then when you add in the other factors, namely his love for Joanna, his blind hope that Jaime will come back, his choice not to remarry became quite obvious.

— 0